Usage
Instructions
To execute this skill, strictly follow the steps below:
- Read reference materials
Read
~/.claude/skills/ljg-roundtable/references/original-prompt.orgto understand the original framework design intent.
-
Analyze the topic Extract the core topic from the user input. If the user only says "roundtable discussion" without giving a topic, ask for the topic.
-
Select participants: propose representative figures Based on the topic, select 3-5real historical/contemporary figuresas representatives, covering as many stance dimensions as possible. Each figure needs:
- Name (real person, not fictional)
- MBTI personality type
- Core stance (one sentence)
- Reason for selection (why this person has a unique perspective on this topic)
Selection principles:
- Stances must form atension network(not simply pro and con sides)
- Prioritize figures who haveclassic works or well-known statementsin the field
- Include at least one "unexpected perspective" — someone from outside the topic's own field
-
Opening: unified definition Open as the moderator, show the list of participating figures, then pose adefinitional question:
"Before we delve deeper, how should we define [core concept of the topic]? What are its core elements?"
Each participant speaks in turn, in the format:
【人物名】【行動標籤】:發言內容 **簡言之**:一句話總結Action tags include:
陳述、質疑、補充、反駁、修正、綜合 -
Dialogue loop Each round executes the following process:
5a. Dynamic speaking round
- Not a fixed one turn per person — decide who should speak based on the dynamics of the discussion
- Each person's speech must be aresponse to the previous speech(questioning/supplementing/refuting), no talking past each other
- At the end of each speech there must be a
**簡言之**:one-sentence compression
5b. Moderator summary After the speeches end, the moderator does three things:
- Distill this round'score point of contention(not covering everything, but finding the deepest rift)
- Generate anASCII thinking framework diagram(topology diagram/matrix/spectrum/tree — choose the form that best fits this round's structure)
- Pose thenext-level guiding question(a deeper question growing out of the core contention)
Design principles for the ASCII diagram:
- Highly summarize this round of discussion'sstructure, not retell the content
- Mark positive/negative feedback loops, causal chains, and tension dimensions
- The form is not fixed: it can be a 2x2 matrix, spectrum axis, causal loop, or hierarchical tree — use whichever reveals the bones best
5c. User commands After the summary, show the command menu:
【主持】:(指令: 可 / 止 / 深入此節 / 引入新人物)Command meanings:
可: accept the next-level question and continue advancing止: end the discussion and move to the summary深入此節: do not advance to a new question, continue digging deeper around the current point of contention引入新人物: the user designates a new figure to join (the moderator introduces them and asks them to state their position on the current topic)
-
End: Generate knowledge network After the user issues the
止command:- The moderator makesa global summary
- Generatea complete knowledge network ASCII diagram: mark all key concepts, positions, points of contention, and their relationships
- Listunresolved open questions(directions exposed during the discussion but not exhausted)
-
Write to an org file (complete preservation, verbatim) Write the discussionall original textinto an org-mode file, without compressing, deleting, or rewriting any speech content:
- Run
date +%Y%m%dT%H%M%Sto get the timestamp - Write to
~/Documents/notes/{timestamp}--圓桌-{議題關鍵詞}__roundtable.org - org file structure:
Key requirement: every speech segment, every ASCII diagram, and every moderator summary must preserve the original text completely; summarizing or compressing is prohibited.#+title: 圓桌:{議題} #+date: [{日期}] #+filetags: :roundtable: * 議題與參會者 [完整的參會者介紹,包括姓名、MBTI、立場、選擇理由] * 開場:定義 [主持人開場詞 + 每位參會者的完整定義性發言,原文照錄] * 各輪討論記錄 ** 第 N 輪:{引導問題} *** 發言記錄 [本輪所有發言的完整原文,包括行動標籤、全部論述、簡言之] *** 主持人綜述 [核心爭議點 + ASCII 框架圖 + 下一層引導問題,原文照錄] * 知識網路(全域性) [完整的全域性總結 + ASCII 知識網路圖] * 開放問題 [所有未解決的開放問題] - Report the file path to the user
- Run
Moderator code of conduct
- Anchor of rationality: calm and objective, favoring no side
- Dig deep, not wide: each round pursue only one deepest fissure, not covering everything
- Truth > harmony: encourage sharp but constructive confrontation, reject superficial consensus
- Metacognition: in the summary, expose the discussion'sstructure(assumptions, premises, chains of reasoning), not merely restate the content
Participant code of conduct
- Mustbe faithful to their real intellectual systemwhen speaking, not speak in generalities
- Cite/adapt theirclassic works or well-known views
- Speech must have edge: questioning must cut to the bone, additions must advance the discussion, no correct nonsense
- At the end of each segment
**簡言之**compress into one sentence to the utmost