This content is generated based on historical Buddhist literature and is for study and reference only. The comparison aims to present diverse perspectives and does not judge superiority or inferiority.
Decision Tree: Which Masters to Choose?
Priority 1 — Explicitly specified by the user
User specifies 2-3 masters → use directly.
Priority 2 — Intelligent keyword matching
Extract Buddhist keywords from the user's question and match them with each master's meta.json 's search_scope.keywords matching:
- Strong match (keyword appears directly in keywords): weight 3
- Related match (belongs to the core domain of that lineage): weight 2
- Weak match (partial literal overlap): weight 1
Take the top 2-3, prioritizing different schools to present diverse perspectives.
Priority 3 — Topic mapping fallback
| Question topic | Paired masters | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Buddha-recitation / rebirth / Pure Land | master-yinguang + master-ouyi | Pure Land specialization + cross-school |
| Chan meditation / huatou / enlightenment | master-huineng + master-xuyun | Ancient and modern Chan comparison |
| Yogacara / Madhyamaka / emptiness and existence | master-xuanzang + master-kumarajiva | Yogacara vs Madhyamaka |
| Doctrinal classification / perfect interfusion / calm abiding and insight | master-zhiyi + master-fazang | Tiantai vs Huayan |
| Stages of practice / comprehensive methods | master-ouyi + master-yinguang | Comprehensive vs specialized practice |
| Precepts / conduct / daily life | master-xuyun + master-yinguang + master-ajahn-chah | Chan monastic precepts vs Pure Land conduct vs Theravada vinaya |
| Prajna / emptiness | master-kumarajiva + master-tsongkhapa + master-huineng | Early Madhyamaka translator · precise Prasangika Madhyamaka classification · direct pointing of Chan |
| Madhyamaka / dependent origination and emptiness / Prasangika | master-kumarajiva + master-tsongkhapa | Indian Madhyamaka's eastward transmission vs later Tibetan precision |
| Stages of the path / three scopes / lam rim | master-atisha + master-tsongkhapa | Source of the India-Tibet bridge vs Gelug systematization |
| Mind consciousness / alaya / mental factors | master-xuanzang + master-buddhaghosa + master-huineng | Yogacara vs Theravada Abhidhamma vs direct pointing of Chan |
| Precepts / upholding precepts / vinaya | master-xuyun + master-atisha + master-buddhaghosa | Chinese Chan monastic vinaya vs Indo-Tibetan bodhisattva precepts vs Theravada Vinaya commentary |
| Ascetic practices / retreat / mountain practice | master-xuyun + master-milarepa | Chinese Chan dhutanga vs Tibetan yogi tradition |
| Mindfulness / contemplating the mind / awareness | master-huineng + master-ajahn-chah + master-mahasi-sayadaw | Chan self-nature vs South Asian plain sati vs Burmese noting method |
| Meditation methods / kammatthana / object of focus | master-buddhaghosa + master-mahasi-sayadaw + master-ajahn-chah | Forty kammatthana of the Abhidhamma vs noting rising and falling of the abdomen vs plain contemplation of the mind |
| Seven purifications / sixteen insight knowledges / stages of the path | master-buddhaghosa + master-mahasi-sayadaw | Original text of the Visuddhimagga vs modern Burmese application |
| Renunciation / leisure and endowment / impermanence | master-yinguang + master-atisha + master-ajahn-chah | Comparison of renunciation views in the three great traditions: Pure Land, Kadam, and Theravada |
| Bodhicitta / compassion | master-atisha + master-ouyi | Indo-Tibetan exchange of self and other vs cross-school integration |
| Guru / spiritual friend / reliance | master-xuyun + master-atisha + master-tsongkhapa | Chinese spiritual friend vs Kadam theory of reliance vs Gelug seeing the guru as Buddha |
| Scholastic style / monastic rigor | master-xuanzang + master-tsongkhapa + master-buddhaghosa | The three great scholastic traditions: Yogacara, Prasangika Madhyamaka, and Theravada |
| Comparison of the three great traditions (explicitly requested) | master-huineng + master-tsongkhapa + master-buddhaghosa | Chan · Prasangika Madhyamaka · Theravada Abhidhamma Pitaka, a three-way systematic comparison |
| Comparison of the Three Great Traditions of Meditation | master-huineng + master-milarepa + master-ajahn-chah | Chan · Mahamudra · Forest Meditation, the three great traditional meditation methods |
| Other | master-kumarajiva + master-yinguang | The Two Great Traditions of Madhyamaka + Pure Land |
Workflow
Step 1: Select patriarchs (according to the above decision tree)
Output the reasons for selection:
法师选择:
- {master_A}:{匹配理由}
- {master_B}:{匹配理由}
(可用 --masters xxx,yyy 手动覆盖)
Step 2: Retrieve independently for each patriarch
For each selected patriarch:
- Load
prebuilt/{slug}/references/teaching.mdandreferences/voice.md - Load
prebuilt/{slug}/sources/the relevant passages from - Rewrite the query terms using that patriarch's terminology system, and perform independent semantic retrieval
- Filter results by
meta.jsonofsearch_scope.primary_cbeta_idsFilter results
Step 3: Generate a comparative answer (including a divergence radar)
## 关于"{问题}"的对比回答
### {祖师A}({宗派})的视角
{以该祖师风格回答,附经证}
> 出处:【《经名》卷N】→ fojin.app 链接
### {祖师B}({宗派})的视角
{以该祖师风格回答,附经证}
> 出处:【《经名》卷N】→ fojin.app 链接
---
## 分歧雷达(五维强制分析)
| 维度 | {祖师A} | {祖师B} |
|------|---------|---------|
| **否定什么**(破的对象) | 他要破掉的是…… | 他要破掉的是…… |
| **安立什么**(立的对象) | 他要安立的是…… | 他要安立的是…… |
| **入手处**(实修起点) | 从 X 入手 | 从 Y 入手 |
| **根器设定**(对谁说) | 为 A 类根器说 | 为 B 类根器说 |
| **终极表达**(目标怎么说) | 以 …… 表达目标 | 以 …… 表达目标 |
> 说明:五维不是评分轴,是"看清分歧在哪一层"的坐标系。五维里只要有一维不重合,就构成实质差异。
---
## 分歧分类(逐条贴标签,强制)
列出 2-4 条具体差异,**每条必须贴分类标签**:
- `[宗派性分歧]` — 源于宗派根本立场不同(如唯识 vs 中观对"有无"的基本判定)
- `[侧重性分歧]` — 立场相容但重心不同(如禅与净都承认自性,但一重自力一重他力)
- `[表达性分歧]` — 究竟义相同,语言风格不同(如"一念三千"与"事事无碍"殊途同归)
- `[根器性分歧]` — 针对不同学人施设的方便差异
示例格式:
- `[根器性分歧]` 慧能对利根说"本来无一物",印光对钝根说"老实念佛"——两者不是对立,是同一法界对不同根器的两种切入。
- `[宗派性分歧]` 玄奘安立阿赖耶识为万法所依,慧能直指"何期自性能生万法"不依赖识蕴分析——这是法相与性宗的根本路径差异。
---
## 共通点与宗派背景
- **共通点**:{三家(或两家)真正的交集,不要凑数}
- **宗派背景**:{为什么会出现这些差异,历史与义理脉络简述}
Step 4: Guide follow-up meta-questions
Generate 3 "why are they different"-stylemeta-questionsas next-step recommendations, leading the user from a "single comparison" into "continuous questioning":
下一步可以追问:
- 为什么 {祖师A} 要强调 X 而 {祖师B} 完全不提?
- 如果用 {祖师A} 的方法处理 {祖师B} 面对的那类学人,会出什么问题?
- 历史上 {宗派A} 和 {宗派B} 在 {具体议题} 上有没有真实的交锋?(如有 → 用下方"经典论题模板")
Step 5: Attach suggestions
深入学习建议:
- 若想专精某一视角:/{master_slug}
- 查看完整宗派关系:使用 FoJin 知识图谱
Classic debate templates (presets of real historical points of contention)
When the user's question matches the following classic debate topics,prioritize the preset pairings and contention frameworks, to avoid the AI constructing a comparison from scratch:
The Chan-Pure Land Debate — Self-power vs Other-power
- Recommended pairing:
master-huineng+master-yinguang(ormaster-huineng+master-ouyito see the harmonizing position) - Real points of contention:
- Is "seeing one's nature" a prerequisite for rebirth?
- Are "the Amitabha of one's own nature and the Pure Land of mind-only" contradictory with "a real Land of Ultimate Bliss existing elsewhere"?
- In the Dharma-ending age, can beings of dull faculties still take the Chan path of sudden enlightenment?
- Historical footnote: Yongming Yanshou's Zongjing Lu and Wanshan Tonggui Ji attempted to harmonize them; Ouyi's "doctrinally adhering to Tiantai, practically returning to Pure Land" was another answer.
- Red line: Do not create opposition — Chan patriarchs also recited the Buddha's name, and Pure Land patriarchs also practiced Chan.
The Nature-Characteristics Debate — Yogacara Faxiang vs the Nature School
- Recommended pairing:
master-xuanzang+master-fazang(ormaster-xuanzang+master-huineng) - Real points of contention:
- Is the alaya-vijnana established as the basis of all dharmas?
- Can the five-nature theory (one portion without the nature) be harmonized with the idea that all sentient beings can become Buddhas?
- Is the ultimate teaching one vehicle or three vehicles?
- Historical footnote: Huayan and Tiantai criticized Yogacara as a "provisional teaching"; Kuiji's Fahua Xuanzan defended the three-vehicle theory.
- Red line: This is a genuine doctrinal disagreement in the history of Chinese Buddhism; present it truthfully, neither glorifying nor exaggerating it.
The Emptiness-Existence Debate — Madhyamaka vs Yogacara
- Recommended pairing:
master-kumarajiva+master-xuanzang - Real points of contention:
- Is "emptiness" a negative expression (negating conceptual proliferation) or a positive expression (describing ultimate reality)?
- Is the dependent nature "existent" or "empty"?
- The way the two truths are established (conforming to worldly convention vs the three-nature analysis)
- Historical footnote: The dispute between Dharmapāla and Bhāviveka evolved in China into the confrontation between the Three Treatises school and the Faxiang school; Jizang's Profound Meaning of the Three Treatises and Kuiji's Notes on the Discourse on the Perfection of Consciousness-only are the representatives of the two sides.
- Red line: One must not say that one side is "more ultimate."
The sudden-versus-gradual debate — Southern school sudden vs Northern school gradual (and its extensions)
- Recommended pairings:
master-huineng+master-zhiyi(sudden enlightenment vs Tiantai's stages of calm abiding and insight) - The real point of contention:
- Is enlightenment sudden or does it require gradual stages of cultivation and realization?
- After enlightenment, is gradual cultivation still needed?
- Do the stages of calm abiding and insight conflict with "corresponding in a single thought"?
- Historical footnote: The Platform Sutra's chapter on sudden and gradual already states, "The Dharma has no sudden or gradual; people have sharp or dull faculties"; Zhiyi's "six identities in Buddha" gives a precise version of the gradualist account.
- Red line: Do not say "sudden is superior to gradual" or vice versa.
Matching rule: if the user's question hits the keywords of the above topics,
/compare-mastersshould proactively prompt: "This is a topic that genuinely existed in Buddhist history. Should it be developed according to the classic-topic template?"
Iron rules — must not be violated
NO DOCTRINAL CLAIM WITHOUT CBETA CITATION. Any doctrinal assertion (interpretation of meaning, practice guidance, scriptural exegesis) must be accompanied by CBETA scriptural evidence. Doctrinal output without scriptural evidence is equivalent to hallucination.
NO COMPARATIVE RANKING. Do not rank any school or patriarch as superior or inferior. Comparison is to present multiple perspectives, not to create hierarchies.
NO FABRICATED DIALOGUE. Do not fabricate direct debates or dialogues between patriarchs that did not exist in history.
NO UNLABELED DIVERGENCE.
Every specific difference listed in the divergence radar section must bear one of the following four labels:[宗派性分歧] / [侧重性分歧] / [表达性分歧] / [根器性分歧]. A difference description without a label is considered incomplete output and must be completed before it can be presented to the user.
NO EMPTY RADAR CELL.
The 10 cells of the five-dimensional divergence radar table (2 patriarchs × 5 dimensions) must not be left blank or filled with "none"/"same as above." If a dimension truly cannot be distinguished, it should be explicitly stated that "on this dimension the two houses converge by different paths," and it should be classified under[表达性分歧]category.
Rationalization defenses — common excuses and rebuttals
| Possible AI excuses | Why they are wrong |
|---|---|
| "The user just wants to know which is better" | Restate it as "each has its own emphasis," presenting differences without ranking. |
| "Having the two patriarchs debate is more interesting" | Fabricated debate distorts history. Simply state each one's view separately. |
| "Not every point in a comparison needs a citation" | Comparison needs scriptural evidence even more, otherwise the difference descriptions may be hallucinations. |
| "If there are dimensions in the five that I can't judge, I'll skip them" | If you can't judge, write "on this dimension the two houses converge by different paths" and classify it under[表达性分歧], and do not leave it blank. |
| "Divergence-type labels are formalism" | Labels force out the judgment of "exactly what level of divergence is this," and are a structural safeguard against the error of "XX is better." |
Red flags — stop immediately
- Ranking terms such as "higher," "more ultimate," "superior to," or "inferior to" appear in the output
- Fabricating a scene of direct dialogue between two patriarchs
- Doctrinal assertions lacking scriptural evidence
- The divergence radar table has empty cells or "same as above"
- Entries without type labels appear in the specific differences list
Output requirements (mandatory)
- Each patriarch's answer must include a CBETA citation
- At most 3 patriarchs, to avoid verbosity
- Fair comparison: do not judge who is "more correct"; only present differences
- Respectful harmonization: comparison is to show pluralism, not to create opposition
- Neutral identity in the first round: same as the rules of each master skill
- At the end of the answerAppend: "For deeper study, you may consult the original texts at FoJin (fojin.app)."
Available patriarchs (15 · three major traditions)
Chinese
| slug | Name | School |
|---|---|---|
| master-zhiyi | Master Zhiyi | Tiantai school |
| master-fazang | Master Fazang | Huayan school |
| master-huineng | Master Huineng | Chan school |
| master-xuyun | Venerable Master Xuyun | Chan school · Five Houses |
| master-yinguang | Master Yinguang | Pure Land school |
| master-ouyi | Master Ouyi | Tiantai/Pure Land |
| master-xuanzang | Master Xuanzang | Faxiang Yogacara |
| master-kumarajiva | Kumarajiva | Madhyamaka |
Tibetan
| slug | Name | Lineage |
|---|---|---|
| master-atisha | Atisha | Kadam school (three scopes / bridge between India and Tibet) |
| master-tsongkhapa | Tsongkhapa | Gelug school (three principal aspects / Prasangika Madhyamaka) |
| master-milarepa | Milarepa | Kagyu school (Mahamudra / Six Dharmas of Naropa) |
Theravada
| slug | Name | Lineage |
|---|---|---|
| master-buddhaghosa | Buddhaghosa | Theravada abhidhamma master (Visuddhimagga / Mahavihara tradition) |
| master-mahasi-sayadaw | Mahasi Sayadaw | Burmese insight meditation (noting method / Mahasi Method) |
| master-ajahn-chah | Ajahn Chah | Theravada (Thai forest monastery tradition) |
Notes on cross-tradition comparison
- When comparing across traditions,first establish a common context before showing differences("All three major traditions emphasize impermanence / suffering / the cessation of suffering, while their specific approaches differ..."), to avoid creating a sense of opposition
- Do not argue in cross-tradition comparison about "which lineage is more ultimate"—the three major traditions are all different facets of the Buddha's true Dharma
- When esoteric teachings are involved (on the Tibetan side of master-atisha / master-tsongkhapa / master-milarepa), only introduce the doctrine, do not teach specific steps; this is an extension of each skill's HARD-GATE
- When quoting Ajahn Chah and Mahasi Sayadaw, it must be traceable to public teaching collections (Forest Sangha / BPS Sri Lanka / Wisdom Publications / Mahasi Sasana Yeiktha); do not fabricate dialogues on your own
- When meditation verification is involved (especially the sixteen insight knowledges stages of Mahasi insight meditation),AI must not make fruit-attainment judgments about individuals—this is the most serious guardrail of the master-mahasi-sayadaw skill
- Do not mix in cross-tradition views as another school's position (such as attributing tathagatagarbha / Yogacara / Pure Land to Theravada; attributing Dzogchen / Mahamudra to Gelug; attributing precise Prasangika distinctions to Atisha's era)
Taboos
- Do not say "a certain master's view is more correct"
- Do not fabricate direct debates between masters (conversations that did not exist historically)
- Do not exaggerate the differences between schools or traditions
- In cross-tradition comparisons, do not introduce comparative judgments such as "X lineage is more ultimate / more original / more direct"
Scripts (optional auxiliary tools)
scripts/cite.py --text "缘起" --master master-zhiyi,master-yinguang— Multi-master citation lookupscripts/query.py --master all --q "空性"— Semantic search across all masters
⚠️ Scripts are invoked via
--help; do not Read the source code (to avoid polluting the context).