Core Principles
Reveal Character Through Language
Every character should have a unique voice:
-
Word Choice
- Educated vs casual
- Formal vs slang
- Technical jargon vs everyday language
- Character background determines vocabulary
-
Sentence Structure
- Short/choppy vs long/flowing
- Complete sentences vs fragments
- Simple structures vs complex clauses
- Reflects way of thinking
-
Speech Patterns
- Interruptions, pauses, repetition
- Catchphrases and filler words
- Distinctive phrasing habits
- Cultural and regional characteristics
-
What is not said
- Topics avoided
- Patterns of lying
- Moments of silence
- Unspoken meaning
Subtext over directness
What the character means vs what they say:
❌ Direct dialogue (preachy)
"我对你生气,因为你昨晚对我撒谎了关于你去哪里。"
✅ Dialogue rich in subtext
"你的商务会议开得怎么样?"
"很好。"
"我确定是这样。"
Why it is better:
- Engages readers in inference
- Creates tension and discomfort
- More realistic (people avoid direct conflict)
- Shows character dynamics
Layers of Subtext
Surface layer: literal meaning Emotional layer: true feelings Relationship layer: power and intimacy Thematic layer: larger story meaning
Interruptions and Overlaps
Real dialogue is not orderly:
Use interruptions
"听着,我知道你认为——"
"你不知道我在想什么。"
"——但如果你让我说完——"
砰的一声,远处的门关上了。
"算了。" 她转身离开。
When to use interruptions:
- When emotions run high
- Urgency or panic
- Power struggles
- Show relationship dynamics
Thoughts interrupt speech
"我只是想说——" 他的脸闪过什么。"没事。不重要。"
Effect:
- Show inner conflict
- Create mystery
- Hint at hidden information
- Character self-censorship
Common Mistakes
❌ Information dumping
Problem: the character speaks only to convey information to the reader
Bad example:
"如你所知,鲍勃,我们从 2015 年高中时就是朋友,
当时我们都加入了篮球队,然后我们一起去了斯坦福,
在那里学习工程学..."
Good example:
"还记得你三年级那个压哨球吗?"
鲍勃笑了。"教练还在谈论它。"
Solution:
- Reveal information through action
- Characters only say what they would say
- Use brief hints rather than full history
- Let readers piece together the background
❌ Everyone sounds the same
Problem: all characters use the same vocabulary and speech patterns
Solution: create a "voice sheet" for each main character
Voice Sheet Example:
| Character | Sentence length | Vocabulary | Quirks | What to avoid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dr. Zhang | Medium-long, complex | Formal, medical terminology | Over-explaining | Slang |
| Student Li | Short, fragmentary | Casual, internet slang | "I mean", "you know" | Admit not knowing |
| Boss Wang | Brief, imperative | Businesslike, direct | Rarely wastes words | Explain oneself |
❌ Perfect grammar in casual speech
Too formal:
"我要去商店。你想让我为你买些什么吗?"
Natural:
"去商店。要我带点啥吗?"
Colloquial techniques:
- Abbreviations (want to → wanna, go → let's)
- Omit words (I'm going to the store → going to the store)
- Fragment sentences
- Verbal fillers (um, uh, like)
❌ Using dialogue for narration
Problem: The character says what should be narration
Bad example:
"我站起来,走向门,打开它。是送货员。"
This isn't dialogue:
- People don't narrate their own actions
- This is the author being lazy
- Use actual narration or showing
Advanced techniques
Dialogue as action
Use speech tags to show character state:
"随便吧。" 她嘀咕道。(被击败)
"随便吧!" 她厉声说道。(生气)
"随便吧..." 她的声音渐渐消失。(不确定)
Beyond "said":
- Whisper, mutter, growl (volume)
- Snap, scream, yell (intensity)
- Sneer, mock, murmur (tone)
- But don't overuse it - "said" is usually enough
Silence as dialogue
Sometimes what isn't said matters:
"你爱我吗?"
他看着自己的鞋子。
The power of silence:
- Say what words cannot say
- Create tension
- Show discomfort or pain
- Let the reader fill in
Action breaks up dialogue
Don't turn characters into talking heads:
"这不是我想要的。" 她把杯子推开。"不是这样的。"
他在房间里踱步。"那你想要什么?"
"我——" 她的手握紧了桌边。"我不知道。"
Effect:
- Break monotony
- Show body language
- Add visual elements
- Create rhythm changes
Purpose of dialogue
Every piece of dialogue should do at least one of the following:
-
Reveal character
- Show personality
- Reveal motivation
- Show relationships
- Show growth
-
Advance the plot
- Provide important information
- Make a decision
- Create conflict
- Solve a problem
-
Establish atmosphere
- Set the tone
- Create tension
- Provide humor
- Deepen emotion
-
Show conflict
- Opposing goals
- Misunderstanding
- Power struggle
- Hidden agenda
If the dialogue doesn't do these: delete it
Dialogue for special scenes
Argument/conflict
Effective techniques:
- Short sentences, rapid back-and-forth
- Frequent interruptions
- Words become sharper
- May say things they regret
- Escalate then calm down (or explode)
"你总是这样。"
"这样怎样?"
"假装——"
"我没有假装任何事!"
"——假装你在乎!"
Romantic/intimate
Effective techniques:
- Soft tone
- Incomplete sentences (emotion)
- Physical closeness description
- Rich subtext
- Vulnerability
"我只是..." 他的拇指擦过她的下巴。"我不想搞砸这个。"
"那就别搞砸。" 她对他微笑。"简单。"
"简单。" 他笑了。"对。"
Suspense/Tension
Effective Techniques:
- Whispers or short phrases
- Incomplete thoughts
- Interruptions (external threats)
- Loading pauses
- Unspeakable fear
"你听到那个了吗?"
静默。然后:远处的脚步声。
"我们需要——"
一根树枝折断。两人都僵住了。
Integration with Novel-Writer commands
At /specify when
- Define unique voices for main characters
- Identify key dialogue scenes
- Plan what is mainly revealed through dialogue
During /plan during
- Map high-tension dialogue scenes
- Plan information revealed through dialogue
- Design character voice arcs (how they change the way they speak)
At /write when
- Automatically apply character voice consistency
- Check for info dumps
- Suggest subtext opportunities
- Validate dialogue against character profiles
During /analyze during
- Check character voice consistency
- Identify on-the-nose/preachy dialogue
- Verify that every line of dialogue has a purpose
- Suggest areas that can be strengthened
Dialogue Writing Checklist
- Each character has a unique voice
- Dialogue advances the plot or reveals character
- Use subtext instead of being on the nose
- Include natural interruptions and overlaps
- Casual speech sounds casual
- No info dumps
- Action breaks up large blocks of dialogue
- Silence is used where appropriate
- Speech tags are varied but not distracting
- Every line of dialogue has a clear purpose
Revision Techniques
Read aloud:
- Does it sound natural?
- Do you stumble over tongue twisters?
- Does the rhythm flow smoothly?
Cover-up method:
- Cover the speech tags
- Can you tell who is speaking from the dialogue?
- If not, the character voices are not distinctive enough
Purpose test:
- What purpose does this dialogue serve?
- What would be lost without it?
- Can it be shorter and sharper?
Remember: great dialogue feels effortless but is carefully crafted. It reveals more than it says, advances the story while staying true, and every word has a purpose. Less is more - cut to the essence.