SuperAPI AI Directory

windows

General & other

View repository

Updated 10-16 06:43

About this skill

Windows VM (UTM + noVNC + agent-browser)

Start a UTM Windows VM, bring up a noVNC bridge, and drive the guest from a browser session. A fast path skips setup when everything is already running; recipes cache sequences that worked.

Inputs

  • $action: (optional) what to do, e.g. "open Notepad". Special values:
    • close = tear down the browser session only (leave the VM running).
    • stop / shutdown = shut Windows down properly from the inside, then quit UTM.
  • The action may also name a target from config.json, or one of its aliases.

References — read the relevant one before you need it

File Read it when
references/config.md writing or extending config.json, or a key is missing
references/input.md before your first click or keystroke on a target, and whenever input stops working
references/troubleshooting.md anything looks frozen, black, stale or off by a factor
references/keyboard-layouts.md guest_keyboard is not us, or typed text comes out wrong
references/shared-folder.md moving files in or out, or a guest dialog hangs
references/guest-channel.md noVNC and vncdo are both insufficient, or you need real work done inside the guest
references/recipes.md saving, loading or writing a recipe

Configuration

Everything machine-specific lives in config.json in this skill's directory. No hostname, UUID, port or personal path appears in this file, so the skill can be shared as-is; each user brings their own config. Standard install locations (UTM's app bundle and container) do appear, and the ones that genuinely vary — novnc_path, websockify — are config keys.

If config.json is missing, or a key you need is absent — HALT. Print the setup block below and stop. Never fall back to config.example.json, and never guess a value: a wrong UUID starts someone else's VM, and a wrong ssh_host connects to a machine that is not yours.

Copy config.example.json to config.json and fill in vm_uuid and bundle. Get the UUID with /Applications/UTM.app/Contents/MacOS/utmctl list.

Minimum config — two fields, everything else defaults:

{ "vm_uuid": "XXXXXXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXXXXXXXXXX", "bundle": "Windows.utm" }

For several VMs, target selection, and the full key table, see references/config.md.

Loading it

# SKILL_DIR = the directory you loaded this SKILL.md from. This file is not an executed
# script, so there is no $0 to derive it from — substitute the literal path (it is
# usually ~/.claude/skills/windows, often a symlink to a checkout elsewhere).
SKILL_DIR=<directory this SKILL.md was loaded from>
CFG="$SKILL_DIR/config.json"

TARGET=<chosen target key>          # $action alias match → target key → default_target
SSH_HOST=<ssh_host or empty>
VNCHOST=<vnc_host>
VNCPORT=<vnc_port>                  # port ON THE VM HOST
TUNNEL_PORT=<tunnel_local_port or empty>
VMDIR=<bundle>
VMUUID=<vm_uuid>
BRIDGE_PORT=<bridge_port>
SESSION=<session_name>

# What websockify and vncdo connect to on THIS Mac:
if [[ -n "$TUNNEL_PORT" ]]; then BRIDGE_TARGET="localhost:$TUNNEL_PORT"
else                             BRIDGE_TARGET="$VNCHOST:$VNCPORT"; fi

# Run a command on whichever machine hosts the VM.
# It takes ONE string and runs it through a shell, so redirects, pipes and || work
# the same locally and remotely. Quote every call site accordingly.
run() {
  if [[ -n "$SSH_HOST" ]]; then ssh "$SSH_HOST" "$1"
  else                          bash -c "$1"; fi
}

PLIST=~/Library/Containers/com.utmapp.UTM/Data/Documents/$VMDIR/config.plist

# Scratch for this run. Fixed /tmp names collide with another session of the same user,
# and screenshots here are full captures of someone's desktop.
RUNDIR=$(umask 077; mktemp -d "/tmp/windows-skill.XXXXXX")

Put every screenshot, log and marker under $RUNDIR and delete it when you finish. The one deliberate exception is the readiness marker below, which has to outlive the run.

Validate every value before it reaches a shell command. vm_uuid must match the UUID shape; vnc_port, tunnel_local_port and bridge_port must be integers in range; and ssh_host, bundle, vnc_host, novnc_path, websockify, session_name, shared_folder, the target names and their aliases must contain no whitespace, quotes, ;, |, &, $, newlines or backticks — every one of them is substituted into a command line, several of them unquoted. You may not be the person who wrote that file.

run must be a function, not a variable. In zsh an unquoted variable is not word-split — SSHP="ssh host"; $SSHP ls fails with command not found: ssh host. Add 2>/dev/null and the command vanishes without a trace, looking like it succeeded.

And it must go through a shell on both branches. A run() { "$@"; } local branch execs its arguments directly, so run 'pgrep -x UTM >/dev/null || open -a UTM' looks for a program with that entire sentence as its name — which fails on the local target only, while the remote target works. Use one string plus bash -c, as above.

Anything you want expanded on the far side must be escaped: \$(date …) inside a double-quoted run argument, or the host's own value is substituted before it is sent.

$PLIST expands locally, which is right only if the remote user has the same home path. If not, build it on the far side or keep ~/Library/… in single quotes.

The bridge and the browser session always run on this Mac, whatever the target is. Only websockify's upstream address changes.

Hard rules

Rules marked [universal] follow from how UTM/QEMU/noVNC/Win32 work. Rules marked [verify once] were observed on a specific setup and may differ on yours — check them the first time you use a target and record the answer in that target's notes.

Never run two copies of the same VM at once [universal]

Two QEMU processes on the same disk image corrupt it outright. Two copies of one image are less dramatic but still bad: they share a Windows machine SID and often a vm_uuid, so they collide on the network and on anything licence- or identity-bound, and afterwards you cannot tell which copy holds the real data. Either way, run one.

pgrep -f qemu >/dev/null && echo "A VM IS RUNNING LOCALLY"
# every DISTINCT ssh_host across all targets, not just the one you are about to start
for h in $(<every distinct non-null ssh_host in config.json>); do
  ssh -o ConnectTimeout=5 "$h" 'pgrep -f qemu >/dev/null' 2>/dev/null \
    && echo "A VM IS RUNNING ON $h"
done

If one is up and the user asked for another, stop and ask. This is the one place in this skill where asking is mandatory.

The VM is shared. Claim it atomically before you touch it [universal]

GUI automation is exclusive to the foreground window: two sessions at once switch each other's windows, clicks land in the wrong place, and both lose their work — or worse, save something in the wrong place.

Claim with an operation that cannot interleave. mkdir fails if the directory exists, so it is a lock; reading a file and then writing it is not.

# On the VM HOST's own filesystem, not on the shared folder — the share is the least
# reliable thing here, and a lock you cannot read is worse than no lock.
LOCK=/tmp/vm-owner-$VMUUID.lock
if run "mkdir '$LOCK' 2>/dev/null"; then
  run "echo '<session-name> '\$(date +%FT%T) > '$LOCK/held-by'"    # we hold it
else
  run "cat '$LOCK/held-by' 2>/dev/null"                             # someone else does
fi

Everyone driving that VM goes through its host, so a lock there is seen by every session, including ones on other machines. Key it by $VMUUID so two different VMs on one host do not block each other.

  • Refresh held-by as you work (its mtime is the liveness signal). Release it when you are done — including when you abort or hit an error — but only if it is still yours; between your last refresh and now someone may legitimately have taken over:

    run "grep -q '<session-name>' '$LOCK/held-by' 2>/dev/null && rm -rf '$LOCK'"
    
  • When it is taken, do not start anything — not even "just one screenshot", which still switches the foreground window. Do not wait blindly either:

    1. Ask the user who holds it and whether to wait — always available, always correct.
    2. If your harness can address other agent sessions by name and the owner string looks like a session name, ask that session directly. An optimisation, not a requirement.

    Short wait (~10 min) → wait and retry. Long or no answer → tell the user and let them decide.

  • A stale lock is a judgement call, not a timer. An old held-by with no other activity is probably a crashed session — but a long-running import looks identical. Confirm the guest is idle (two screenshots 60 s apart, unchanged) and say what you are doing before you break someone's lock. Never break one on a timer alone.

  • Before releasing, clean up inside the guest. Close the applications and dialogs you opened, and leave the desktop as you found it. Anything you did not open, leave alone.

Never send mouse down without an immediate mouse up [universal]

mouse down and mouse up are separate CLI processes. If anything happens between them, the guest is left holding a button — and the whole input path can wedge: the framebuffer keeps updating, but no input arrives at all, mouse or keyboard, including Escape. Restarting the session or websockify does not clear it; a bare mouse up does.

Do not click in the guest through noVNC. Use vncdo or an in-guest channel for that. Exactly two noVNC pointer uses remain allowed, both emitted as one uninterrupted unit with nothing in between:

  • mouse move alone — a hover, for the tooltip probe. No button involved.
  • mouse move → down → up once, to give the browser canvas focus so keystrokes reach noVNC. That is a focus tap, not a click in the guest, and it is the only place the sequence appears.

Full reasoning and the recovery procedure are in references/input.md.

Only one VNC client at a time [verify once]

Treat the VNC head as exclusive unless a probe proves otherwise on your setup. While noVNC holds it, vncdo capture comes back black or hangs — which looks exactly like a dead VM. Never run vncdo while the browser session is connected: release the session and the bridge first, confirm the upstream socket is gone, then reconnect afterwards. Procedure in references/input.md.

Probe the input channel; never trust a cached answer [verify once]

Which channel reaches the guest is not stable. Observed over months on one VM: the mouse worked, died, worked, worked only via vncdo, died again after a restart — with no configuration change. On the same day two applications in the same guest disagreed about whether the keyboard or the pointer was the working one.

So input_preference in config.json is the order to try, never a verdict. Probe at the start of a session that will do more than take a screenshot (~20 s), and re-probe whenever a step silently does nothing, after any restart, and when the foreground application changes. If nothing is verified, stop and say so — do not "try a click". The probe is in references/input.md.

Bound everything that talks to the VM [universal]

Every vncdo, ssh, nc, share and capture call gets an explicit timeout. Un-bounded, they do not fail — they hang for tens of minutes and look like a dead guest. In particular, never probe a network share with a bare Test-Path; see references/shared-folder.md.

Kill by pid, never by pattern [universal]

pkill -f websockify and friends also kill other sessions' bridges, other agents' work and other people's processes. Resolve the pid first (lsof -t, pgrep -f), look at what you found, then kill that pid.

One deliberate exception: killall UTM. UTM is a single application instance owning every VM on that host, so there is no per-VM process to target — and an osascript quit fails silently over SSH. It is still blunt: it takes down every VM on that machine, so check the other targets' locks on that host first, and never reach for it while another session holds one.

The shared folder is the most fragile link [universal for UTM's WebDAV sharing]

When it dies, every guest dialog that touches it hangs for many minutes, and anything in the guest polling a file there dies with it. Check it is alive before a long series of steps. Recovery order and the safe liveness test: references/shared-folder.md.

A dialog that "ignores the keyboard" usually just lacks focus [universal]

Send alt-tab first, then esc/enter — one alt-tab per stuck dialog. Verified on a pair of windows that had resisted esc, tab+enter and clicking, and which two sessions independently concluded were unreachable by keyboard. They were reachable; the keys were going somewhere else.

VNC has no authentication here [universal]

vnc_display_arg must keep its 127.0.0.1 prefix. Reach the port from another machine through the SSH tunnel this skill sets up — never by binding QEMU to 0.0.0.0.

Fast path (try first, ~0.3 s)

Never call eval on the fast path. Not for cost, but because session list plus a port check answers faster, and eval needs a live connected canvas — exactly what you are still verifying.

# 1. ports listening — VNC on the target, bridge always local
nc -z -w1 ${BRIDGE_TARGET%:*} ${BRIDGE_TARGET##*:} >/dev/null 2>&1 \
  && lsof -nP -iTCP:"$BRIDGE_PORT" -sTCP:LISTEN -t >/dev/null || exit 1
# 2. session exists
agent-browser session list 2>/dev/null | grep -qE "^[[:space:]]*$SESSION\$" || exit 1
# 3. the browser is really attached — without this a zombie session passes:
#    window still open, websocket long dead
lsof -nP -iTCP:"$BRIDGE_PORT" -sTCP:ESTABLISHED -t >/dev/null 2>&1 || exit 1
# 4. marker from the last successful setup, TTL 30 min AND the same target
M=/tmp/windows-skill-ready-$SESSION
[[ -f $M ]] && [[ $(($(date +%s) - $(stat -f %m $M))) -lt 1800 ]] \
  && [[ "$(cat $M)" == "$TARGET" ]] || exit 1
echo "ALL_READY"

ALL_READY → jump to Step 5. Otherwise walk 1–4, and on success echo "$TARGET" > /tmp/windows-skill-ready-$SESSION.

Why the ESTABLISHED check. A session whose websocket dies keeps running and looks alive: session list shows it, the bridge port listens. Measured once: such a session held two cores for 8 hours, because a disconnected noVNC canvas retries forever. The socket is the only reliable evidence — though it is necessary, not sufficient (sockets exist during "Connecting…" too), so the sanity screenshot confirms the handshake completed.

The marker carries the target on purpose. If it only had to exist, switching targets would sail through and you would be talking to the old bridge and the still-running VM behind it.

Sanity verify before the first action (not on the fast path): one screenshot, agent-browser --session "$SESSION" screenshot "$RUNDIR/_vnc.png". If it is dominated by a dark background with the noVNC logo, reconnect (Step 4).

Steps

1. Preflight (only if the fast path failed)

Local tools, in parallel: which agent-browser; <websockify> --help (else pipx install websockify); ls <novnc_path>/vnc.html (else git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/novnc/noVNC.git <novnc_path>); which vncdo (pipx install vncdotool); which cliclick only for start_method: cliclick.

VM configuration, on the target. Read the plist directly rather than through utmctl:

run "/usr/libexec/PlistBuddy -c 'Print :QEMU:AdditionalArguments' '$PLIST'"
run "/usr/libexec/PlistBuddy -c 'Print :Display:0:Hardware' '$PLIST'"

Expected: a non-GL display, and the VNC argument matching vnc_display_arg. A -gl display makes QEMU refuse the VNC console (The console requires a GL context). On the setup this was written against the working value was virtio-ramfb; the right value is whatever your UTM build offers without -gl, so read the current one before changing it. If they match, continue. If not:

  1. If the VM is running, human checkpoint: shut Windows down from the inside over VNC. Poll until the qemu process is gone. Never --force.
  2. Quit UTM — over SSH run "killall UTM" (an osascript quit fails silently over SSH); locally osascript -e 'tell application "UTM" to quit'. Verify with run "pgrep -x UTM".
  3. Back the plist up: run "cp '$PLIST' '$PLIST.bak-$(date +%Y%m%d-%H%M%S)'".
  4. Write the arguments. Add fails if the entry already exists and Set fails if it does not, so read first, pick the right verb, and check each result before the next — a half-written AdditionalArguments leaves the VM unable to boot:
    run "/usr/libexec/PlistBuddy -c 'Add :QEMU:AdditionalArguments:0 string -vnc' '$PLIST'"
    run "/usr/libexec/PlistBuddy -c 'Add :QEMU:AdditionalArguments:1 string <vnc_display_arg>' '$PLIST'"
    run "/usr/libexec/PlistBuddy -c 'Set :Display:0:Hardware <non-GL display>' '$PLIST'"
    
    If anything fails midway, restore the .bak-* you just made and start over.
  5. run "open -a UTM", then Step 2.

2. VM start

First confirm no other copy of this VM is running. Then, by start_method:

utmctl — the normal path, locally and over SSH where Automation is approved:

run 'pgrep -x UTM >/dev/null || open -a UTM'
run "timeout 20 /Applications/UTM.app/Contents/MacOS/utmctl start '$VMUUID'"

Always address the VM by $VMUUID, never by name. Bound the call: without Automation approval utmctl blocks for 120 s before returning -1712, so give it an explicit limit and treat a timeout as "this target needs start_method: cliclick", not as something to retry. (timeout is GNU coreutils — gtimeout from brew install coreutils, or use ssh -o ConnectTimeout plus a server-side bound.)

cliclick — for a Mac nobody is sitting at, where utmctl over SSH hangs. Apple Events need Automation (TCC) approval, and with no one there to click that prompt the call blocks for 120 s and returns -1712. Drive UTM's GUI instead. This needs that Mac to have a logged-in graphical session and to have granted Accessibility and Screen Recording — it is a workaround for an unattended machine, not for a truly headless one:

run 'pgrep -x UTM >/dev/null || open -a UTM'
run "screencapture -x -t png $RUNDIR/s.png"       # find the play button
HOST_LOGICAL_W=${HOST_LOGICAL_RESOLUTION%%x*}    # "1920x1080" -> 1920; empty if unset
[[ -n "$HOST_LOGICAL_W" ]] && run "sips -Z $HOST_LOGICAL_W $RUNDIR/s.png"
run 'cliclick m:<x>,<y> w:300 c:<x>,<y>'          # cliclick_play_xy from config.json

Coordinates are logical points. A scaled panel reports physical pixels in a screenshot but takes clicks in logical points; skip the downscale and every coordinate is off by the scale factor. If someone can approve the Automation prompt once, this detour disappears.

Enlarge the VM window on a remote target, but do NOT full-screen it. True full screen hides the UTM menu bar that drives the VM and covers the rest of that machine's screen. This has no effect on the resolution you see over VNC — the guest decides that.

Poll on the VM host: run "netstat -an" | grep "\.$VNCPORT.*LISTEN", 300 ms step, 60 s over a network, 40 s locally. $VNCPORT is the port on that machine, never the tunnel port.

If tunnel_local_port is set, open the tunnel now, before the bridge:

lsof -nP -iTCP:"$TUNNEL_PORT" -sTCP:LISTEN -t >/dev/null 2>&1 \
  || ssh -fN -L "$TUNNEL_PORT:127.0.0.1:$VNCPORT" "$SSH_HOST"

3. Bridge

The bridge always runs on this Mac, on $BRIDGE_PORT; only its upstream changes. If lsof -i:$BRIDGE_PORT is empty:

<websockify> --web <novnc_path> 127.0.0.1:"$BRIDGE_PORT" "$BRIDGE_TARGET" \
  >"$RUNDIR/novnc.log" 2>&1 &

The 127.0.0.1: prefix is not optional. Without it websockify binds every interface, and noVNC has no authentication — anyone who can reach this Mac gets full view and control of that Windows desktop. Same reasoning as vnc_display_arg.

Poll curl -s -o /dev/null -w "%{http_code}" http://localhost:$BRIDGE_PORT/vnc.html until 200 (100 ms step, 5 s timeout).

When the target changes, close the browser session and stop websockify — the upstream is fixed at launch and cannot be switched. Close the session first: one left open against a dead bridge is exactly the two-core zombie described above. Resolve websockify's pid (lsof -nP -iTCP:"$BRIDGE_PORT" -sTCP:LISTEN -t) and kill that, not a pattern. Kill a stale tunnel the same way, then rebuild both.

4. Browser session (idempotent)

  • No $SESSION → create it. open navigates, so it is two commands:
    agent-browser --session "$SESSION" open "http://localhost:$BRIDGE_PORT/vnc.html?host=localhost&port=$BRIDGE_PORT&autoconnect=true&quality=4"
    agent-browser --session "$SESSION" set viewport <width> <height>   # TWO args, not "1920x1080"
    
  • It exists → verify with a screenshot (no eval). Showing the noVNC logo → goto the bridge URL to reconnect.

The guest's resolution is set inside the guest and cannot be changed from outside. resize=remote is pointless — the server refuses and logs Server did not accept the resize request.

Set the viewport to exactly the guest resolution, or every coordinate is wrong: smaller → noVNC scales down and the taskbar is cut off; larger → the canvas is centred and every coordinate is offset by half the difference; equal → 1:1 at 0,0.

agent-browser --session "$SESSION" eval "(() => { const c=document.querySelector('canvas'); const r=c.getBoundingClientRect(); return c.width+'x'+c.height+' @ '+Math.round(r.left)+','+Math.round(r.top); })()"

You want <guest_resolution> @ 0,0. Different → update guest_resolution and resize. Re-measure after any guest reboot; a reboot can change the resolution and silently invalidate every stored coordinate. (agent-browser takes a script whose value is the last expression; a wrapped IIFE works in every variant, so always write it that way.)

After a goto, do not blind-sleep — poll with screenshots every 300 ms and continue as soon as the dominant colour is no longer the dark noVNC background. Timeout 8 s.

On success: echo "$TARGET" > /tmp/windows-skill-ready-$SESSION.

5. Perform the action

Special $action values:

  • close → agent-browser close --session "$SESSION" and stop. Never --all.
  • stop / shutdown → shut the VM and UTM down per Cleanup.
  • empty → report "pipeline ready" and stop.

Otherwise: look for a recipe, run it if it matches, investigate and save one if not — see references/recipes.md.

Pick the channel before you act, and do not mix two of them in one pass. Before the first click or keystroke on this target, run the input probe (references/input.md).

  • Keyboard-only work (Start menu, typing, Alt+F4, Alt+Tab, dialogs): stay on noVNC. Screenshots and keystrokes share one connection and cost nothing extra.
  • Anything needing a pointer: noVNC keeps the VNC head, so vncdo cannot have it. Group the pointer work together, then: release the session and the bridge → confirm the upstream socket is free → one bounded vncdo call containing move, pause, click and capture → reconnect (Steps 3–4) when the pointer work is finished. Procedure and pitfalls in references/input.md.
  • Real work inside the guest (files, queries, anything scriptable): prefer an in-guest channel over clicking at all — references/guest-channel.md.
  • No channel verified: stop and say so. Do not "just try a click".

Verify after every coordinate-sensitive or destructive step, with a screenshot and a statement of what you expect to see. A click that landed 40 px away and a click that did not arrive look identical until you look.

Cleanup

Clean up inside the VM first, then deal with the session. Close what you opened and release the lock, even when you leave the browser session running.

Default: leave the browser session running. Measured: a connected idle session costs ~10 % of one core and ~270 MB, and websockify adds nothing. Tearing it down and setting it up again costs more than it saves. Close it (never --all) only when the user says /windows close, "done with Windows", or the action itself is close.

That only holds for a session that is genuinely connected — a disconnected one costs two cores, and the ESTABLISHED check catches it next time.

agent-browser session list lists every live session. Never close or touch sessions that are not yours. $SESSION on the noVNC URL → reuse; $SESSION on a different URL → leave it and open <name>2; anything else → leave alone.

Shutting the VM down

Different rule from the browser session: the VM holds its full RAM allocation the whole time it runs, so shut it down once the work is done.

Ask first unless you can show the guest is idle. A shutdown is only "reversible" if nothing is in flight. Idle means all of: the lock is yours; two screenshots 60 s apart are identical; no window shows a progress indicator or an unsaved-changes marker; and you opened everything that is open. Anything less — in particular an application you did not start, which may hold a person's unsaved work — means ask. If someone else holds the lock, do not shut down at all.

Proper shutdown, in this order:

  1. Shut Windows down from the inside, via the keyboard. Alt+F4 on the desktop opens the "Shut down Windows" dialog. Read the selected action in the screenshot before you press Enter — which one is preselected depends on policy and on what the machine did last, and Restart or Sign out look almost identical at a glance.
    agent-browser --session "$SESSION" press "Alt+F4"   # screenshot to see what opened
    agent-browser --session "$SESSION" press "Enter"    # only once you see the dialog
    
    Alt+F4 closes the focused window first, so close applications first (Alt+Tab → Alt+F4) or they block the shutdown. With an in-guest channel, Stop-Computer -Force is the other correct path. Neither utmctl stop nor closing the UTM window is a proper shutdown — both return before the guest is down and leave NTFS unclean.
  2. Wait for the qemu process to disappear (90 s timeout). Check what your UTM version actually names it — it may run QEMU under a helper process rather than as qemu-<arch>.
  3. Close the browser session and websockify (by pid), delete /tmp/windows-skill-ready-$SESSION and $RUNDIR.
  4. Quit UTM — over SSH run "killall UTM"; locally osascript -e 'tell application "UTM" to quit'.

Notes

  • Everything machine-specific is in config.json; this file stays free of hostnames, UUIDs, ports and personal paths so it can be shared.
  • config.json, recipes/ and notes/ are ignored in a fresh clone. If a checkout already tracked them before the ignore rules existed, they are still tracked — verify with git ls-files before pushing anywhere.
  • Screenshots under /tmp are full-desktop captures of someone's working machine. Delete what you no longer need, and look at one before attaching it anywhere.
  • Plist location: ~/Library/Containers/com.utmapp.UTM/Data/Documents/<bundle>/config.plist.
  • Exposing a VNC port across a private network (e.g. tailscale serve --bg --tcp <port> tcp://127.0.0.1:<port>) persists across reboots and needs no re-setup. It also hands unauthenticated view-and-control of that desktop to everything on the tailnet — the SSH tunnel this skill sets up gives you the same reach without that. Prefer the tunnel; reach for serve only knowing what it opens.