Concept Validation Skill
Core Rules
- Before writing any draftmustpass
validate_concept()(except concept.md itself)
- Novelty Score ≥ 75 (all 3 rounds must meet the standard) to pass
- On failuresharp feedback + give options(write directly? revise? use CGU?) → no sycophantic feedback or automatically changing NOVELTY
Tool
| Tool |
Purpose |
When to use |
validate_concept |
Full 3-round validation + novelty scoring |
First validation, after revising concept |
validate_concept_quick |
Structural quick check (no scoring) |
Quick confirmation during the draft stage |
validate_for_section |
Validate a specific section |
Before writing Introduction/Methods |
Novelty scoring criteria
| Score |
Meaning |
Action |
| 90-100 |
Highly innovative, strong selling point |
✅ Write directly |
| 75-89 |
Sufficiently innovative |
✅ Can write, minor adjustments recommended |
| 60-74 |
Insufficient innovation |
⚠️ Concept needs revision |
| <60 |
Lacks innovation |
❌ Must restructure or use CGU |
Validation focus for each Paper Type
| Paper Type |
Required elements |
Validation focus |
| original-research |
Hypothesis, NOVELTY, Methods, SELLING POINTS |
Hypothesis testable, methods feasible |
| case-report |
Case presentation, NOVELTY, Learning points |
Rarity or new insight |
| review-article |
Scope, NOVELTY, Framework |
New perspective or new integration |
| meta-analysis |
PICO, Search strategy, NOVELTY |
Differentiated analysis angle |
| technical-note |
Innovation, NOVELTY, Clinical impact |
Technical novelty |
| letter-to-editor |
Key argument, NOVELTY |
Uniqueness of perspective |
| brief-communication |
Key finding, NOVELTY |
Importance of findings |
Required structure of concept.md
# Research Concept
## Background(為什麼重要)
## 🔒 NOVELTY STATEMENT(創新點,不可刪弱)
## Research Question / Hypothesis
## Methods Overview
## 🔒 KEY SELLING POINTS(賣點,Discussion 必強調)
## Target Journal(選填)
🔒 Protected content rules
🔒 NOVELTY STATEMENT: must not be weakened or deleted, must be reflected throughout the manuscript
🔒 KEY SELLING POINTS: Discussion must emphasize all selling points
- Violation → Hook P5 blocks commit
Validation workflow
- Confirm
concept.md exists:read_draft("concept.md")
- Structural check: all required sections exist
- Run validation:
validate_concept()(3 rounds)
- Result handling:
- ≥75 all pass → notify that writing can begin
- any round <75 → report weaknesses + provide three options
- missing required section → report the gap
Failure handling options
| Option |
Description |
| Write directly |
Accept the risk, skip (requires explicit user consent) |
| Revise concept |
Modify based on feedback concept.md then re-validate |
| Strengthen with CGU |
mcp_cgu_deep_think(find weaknesses) → spark_collision(collide arguments) → revise then re-validate |
Integration with other Skills
| Workflow |
Preceding Skill |
Following Skill |
| concept → validation → draft |
concept-development |
draft-writing |
| auto-paper Phase 4 |
concept-development (Phase 3) |
draft-writing (Phase 5) |
| Hook B1 (post-section) |
— |
Compare concept vs draft |
| Hook P3 (pre-commit) |
— |
Confirm NOVELTY/SELLING POINTS |