Mission
Separate:
observed fact
review claim
repair suggestion
branch liability
kernel impact
permitted disposition
Required decision
review_observation:
observation_id:
artifact_state:
observed_behavior:
required_behavior:
validity:
confirmed |
refuted |
stale |
unknown
liability:
introduced_by_current_diff |
exposed_and_required_by_current_acceptance |
preexisting_but_blocks_current_invariant |
adjacent_preexisting |
reviewer_preference |
unknown
kernel_impact:
existing_law_violation |
additional_witness |
missing_semantic_distinction |
no_kernel_impact |
unknown
acceptance_entailment:
entailed |
scope_expansion |
unknown
reproduction_or_proof:
source_refs: []
disposition:
enter_kernel |
attach_witness |
validate_only |
capture_followup |
reject |
blocked
Hard rules
- Valid does not mean branch-liable.
- Reviewer repair suggestions are not implementation scope.
additional_witnessdoes not create a new code branch or test family.missing_semantic_distinction + scope_expansionreturns to spec/user authority.- Under
$resolve, emit no direct mutation warrant. - Raw review prose must not be handed to an implementer.