The real cause of a long work's collapse is not being unable to keep writing, it iscontradictions before and after, a messy timeline, setting drift—this is especially true when AI writes long works: 50 chapters are normal, at 100 chapters it starts to collapse, by 300 chapters it has completely lost its memory. This skill is the "logic defense line" of a long work, and pairs with memory(memory): the archive is responsible forrecording, and this skill is responsible forchecking。
When to use
- Writing a long work, checking logic once every chapter / few chapters
- Afraid that "later on the setting collapses / characters drift / foreshadowing is forgotten"
- Checking the timeline (whether "three days later" "two months later" is actually messy)
- Checking whether resources / injuries / identities / power levels match up from beginning to end
- Doing a full coherence health check at the end of each volume
- And
reviewdifference:reviewisreader retentionperspective (hooks / payoff moments / making readers keep reading); this skill isauthor backstageperspective (settings do not contradict, logic can be self-consistent)
How to check (seven logic chains + timeline / world state)
Checking chapter by chapter against the archive (01_人物.md / 03_伏笔追踪.md / 07_时间线.md / power-level table / emotional trajectory), see references/continuity-check.md:
- Reasonableness of character behavior — does the behavior have motivation? Does it conflict with the character setting? (A wanted criminal will not go shopping for steamed buns)
- Plot causal chain — is the new setting foreshadowed? Are the pits dug recorded in the foreshadowing table? (Prevent "suddenly popping up / dug but not filled")
- Resource changes — money / props / troops can only increase or decrease according to the plot (prevent "last chapter could not afford food, next chapter pulls out one hundred thousand spirit stones")
- Identity exposure status — maintain the "list of people in the know": who knows the protagonist's true identity / strength / alternate identity (the lifeline of the pretending to be weak to eat the tiger genre)
- Injury / status persistence — severe injury / poisoning / seclusion must persist, and must be fulfilled when it expires (prevent "dying → next chapter fighting three hundred rounds")
- Power level / rank consistency — check against the power-level table; if there is no improvement, do not fight evenly across tiers
- Emotion / relationship continuity — check against the emotional trajectory; jumps need transitions (prevent "just broke up → next chapter laughing happily")
- Timeline + world state — every "after X time" can be converted into a point on the timeline; parallel lines converging do not contradict; deadlines are fulfilled when reached; for strong-setting genres also checkworld state(was the North City they went to already destroyed in the previous chapter, see
worldskill)
Workflow
- First read the archive (if no archive has been built, first use
memoryto initialize, at minimum there must be character status, foreshadowing table, timeline, power-level table). - Read the chapters to be checked, go through the six chains + timeline one by one.
- Producecoherence health check report(format see below), locate contradictions to paragraph / chapter + give fixes.
- Reminder to write this chapter's changes (character status/resources/timeline/people in the know)back into the archive, otherwise the next chapter will keep drifting.
Output: Coherence Check Report
【连贯性体检 · 第 N 章 / 第 X 卷】
时间线:本章 = Day__ |跨度 __ |与主线 一致/冲突
六条逻辑链:行为/因果/资源/身份/伤势/战力 —— 逐条 ✓/✗ + 问题定位
矛盾清单:① 第_段 与 第_章/档案 冲突 → 改法(改本章/回改前文/补一句交代)
待兑现:到期未兑现的期限/伏笔(毒/闭关/约定)
档案待更新:人物状态/资源/时间线/知情人 哪些要写回
Principles
- Pinpoint to the paragraph/chapter, specify which chapter/which archive entry it conflicts with, don't be vague.
- Every contradiction must be givenan executable fix。
- Sort by severity: main plot/combat power/identity are hard flaws to fix first; secondary emotional lines left blank are not a flaw (see
references/human-texture.md"Not closed-loop ≠ bad ending"). - After checking, must remindto write back to the archive— this is the closed loop that prevents amnesia.
Coordinate with
- Memory/Archive/Timeline/Combat Power Table →
memory(references/project-memory.md) - Reader retention five-dimension diagnosis →
review - Fix contradiction chapters →
expandrewrite; foreshadowing payoff →reviewdimension 3.