Steps
1. What must be done, and at what level is the subject stated?
Name the act the subject must support: decide, explain, build, or fix. Name the level it is stated at: does it say why, what, how, or which one?
2. How does it read a few rungs above and a few rungs below?
Write two or three restatements above it, each saying why the rung below matters or what it is a kind of, and two or three below, each saying how or which one. One line per rung. Leave the rungs unexamined until the next step.
3. What does each rung let you do, and what does it hide?
For each rung, name the act it makes possible and the detail it buries or lacks.
4. Which rung do you act at?
Choose the rung with the least detail that still supports the act. Under time pressure, start higher. To explain a fault, work up from the lower rungs; to work out how something should function, work down from the top.
Output
Choose the mode from what you were handed:
- A question set: answer it.
- A request for questions only: write the question set and stop.
- Anything else: write the question set, then answer it.
Write the question set in this form: one question per step, in step order, each reworded to name the subject, so that a reader holding only the set can answer it.
**Subject:** [what is examined, named so it can be found without this conversation]
**Given:**
- [a fact, source, or limit the answers must respect] ([where it came from])
**Questions:**
1. [step 1's question, naming the subject]
2. [step 2's question, naming the subject]
3. [step 3's question, naming the subject]
Answer in this form, keeping each question's number and wording, from the set and from what you can check yourself:
**Subject:** [the subject, as the set names it]
1. [step 1's question, naming the subject]
[the answer]
2. [step 2's question, naming the subject]
Skipped: [why this step does not apply]
3. [step 3's question, naming the subject]
Open: [the fact the answer needs that the set does not give]