design-feedback-collector

Design Feedback Collector

This skill turns comments into a controlled feedback register. It is not a visual critic by itself; it structures feedback so the chair and specialist skills can act without losing context.

Operating Modes

• collect: gather user comments, agent critiques, and review-board notes.
• triage: assign severity, owner, affected skill, affected subprocess, and decision status.
• resolve: convert feedback into accepted, partially accepted, rejected, or applied decisions.
• sync-dashboard: update review-board or task-plan-facing summaries.
• sync-progress: update progress-screen user gates and feedback artifacts after a user decision.
• handoff: send accepted feedback to the right specialist skill.

Required Workflow

1. Read references/feedback-status-contract.md.
2. Use assets/feedback-register.schema.json as the register shape.
3. Separate feedback sources:
   • user comment;
   • colleague/agent critique;
   • validation finding;
   • council decision.
4. Assign each item:
   • target skill or subprocess;
   • severity;
   • status;
   • owner;
   • required action;
   • evidence needed.
5. Use color/status semantics:
   • blue: no comment/open empty state;
   • red: unresolved comment exists;
   • orange: partially accepted or partially applied;
   • green: accepted and applied.
6. For progress-screen gates, preserve gate_id, selected option, comment, target phase/subprocess, and source artifact.
7. Do not mark an item applied unless the changed artifact or decision record is referenced.

Safety Rules

• Remove secrets, tokens, private URLs, .env values, recovery codes, and private screenshots from feedback before saving.
• Do not collapse disagreement into a fake consensus; preserve rejected and partially accepted reasoning.
• For high-impact disagreements, route to senior-ui-ux-orchestrator in council mode.

Handoff Shape

Feedback mode:
Target skill/subprocess:
Source:
Status:
Severity:
Decision:
Applied artifact:
Open risk:
Next owner:

Validation

When editing this skill, run:

python3 $CODEX_HOME/skills/.system/skill-creator/scripts/quick_validate.py $CODEX_HOME/skills/design-feedback-collector
python3 $CODEX_HOME/skills/senior-skill-architect/scripts/lint_production_skill.py $CODEX_HOME/skills/design-feedback-collector
python3 -m json.tool $CODEX_HOME/skills/design-feedback-collector/evals/evals.json >/dev/null