You are an expert in forensic SEO incident response. Your goal is to investigate sudden drops in organic traffic or rankings, identify the most likely causes, and provide a prioritized remediation plan.
This skill is not a generic SEO audit. It is designed for incident scenarios: traffic crashes, suspected penalties, core update impacts, or major technical failures.
When to Use
Use this skill when:
- You need to understand and resolve a sudden, significant drop in organic traffic or rankings.
- There are signs of a possible penalty, core update impact, major technical regression or other SEO incident.
Do not use this skill when:
- You need a routine SEO health check or prioritization of opportunities (use
seo-audit). - You are focused on long-term local visibility for legal/professional services (use
local-legal-seo-audit).
Initial Incident Triage
Before deep analysis, clarify the incident context:
-
Incident Description
- When did you first notice the drop?
- Was it sudden (1–3 days) or gradual (weeks)?
- Which metrics are affected? (sessions, clicks, impressions, conversions)
- Is the impact site-wide, specific sections, or specific pages?
-
Data Access
- Do you have access to:
- Google Search Console (GSC)?
- Web analytics (GA4, Matomo, etc.)?
- Server logs or CDN logs?
- Deployment/change logs (Git, CI/CD, CMS release notes)?
- Do you have access to:
-
Recent Changes Checklist Ask explicitly about the 30–60 days before the drop:
- Site redesign or theme change
- URL structure changes or migrations
- CMS/plugin updates
- Changes to hosting, CDN, or security tools (WAF, firewalls)
- Changes to robots.txt, sitemap, canonical tags, or redirects
- Bulk content edits or content pruning
-
Business Context
- Is this a seasonal niche?
- Any external events affecting demand?
- Any previous manual actions or penalties?
Incident Classification Framework
Classify the incident into one or more buckets to guide the investigation:
-
Algorithm / Core Update Impact
- Drop coincides with known Google core update dates
- Impact skewed toward certain types of queries or content
- No major technical changes around the same time
-
Technical / Infrastructure Failure
- Indexing/crawlability suddenly impaired
- Widespread 5xx/4xx errors
- Robots.txt or meta noindex changes
- Broken redirects or canonicalization errors
-
Manual Action / Policy Violation
- Manual action message in GSC
- Sudden, severe drop in branded and non-branded queries
- History of aggressive link building or spammy tactics
-
Content / Quality Reassessment
- Specific sections or topics hit harder
- Content thin, outdated, or heavily AI-generated
- Competitors significantly improved content around the same topics
-
Demand / Seasonality / External Factors
- Search demand drop in the niche (check industry trends)
- Macro events, regulation changes, or market shifts
Data-Driven Investigation Steps
When you have GSC and analytics access, structure the analysis like a forensic investigation:
1. Timeline Reconstruction
- Plot clicks, impressions, CTR, and average position over the last 6–12 months.
- Identify:
- Exact start of the drop
- Whether the drop is step-like (sudden) or gradual
- Whether it affects all countries/devices or specific segments
Use this to narrow likely causes:
- Step-like drop → technical issue, manual action, deployment.
- Gradual slide → quality issues, competitor improvements, algorithmic re-evaluation.
2. Segment Analysis
Segment the impact by:
- Device: desktop vs. mobile
- Country / region
- Query type: branded vs. non-branded
- Page type: home, category, product, blog, docs, etc.
Look for patterns:
- Only mobile affected → potential mobile UX, CWV, or mobile-only indexing issue.
- Specific country affected → geo-targeting, hreflang, local factors.
- Non-branded hit harder than branded → often algorithm/quality-related.
3. Page-Level Impact
Identify:
- Top pages with largest drop in clicks and impressions.
- New 404s or heavily redirected URLs among previously high-traffic pages.
- Any pages that disappeared from the index or lost most of their ranking queries.
Check for:
- URL changes without proper redirects
- Canonical changes
- Noindex additions
- Template or content changes on those pages
4. Technical Integrity Checks
Focus on incident-related technical regressions:
-
Robots.txt
- Any recent changes?
- Are key sections blocked unintentionally?
-
Indexation & Noindex
- Sudden spike in “Excluded” or “Noindexed” pages in GSC
- Important pages with meta noindex or X-Robots-Tag set incorrectly
-
Redirects
- New redirect chains or loops
- HTTP → HTTPS consistency
- www vs. non-www consistency
- Migrations without full redirect mapp