SuperAPI AI Directory

performance-review

General & other

View repository

Updated 10-15 21:03

About this skill

Performance Review

Overview

Designs and supports the implementation of performance evaluation systems suited to the organization's size and culture. It reflects 2026 trends such as parallel operation of OKR+KPI, AI-based performance analysis, and 360-degree feedback, and establishes a fair evaluation process grounded in compliance with the Labor Standards Act.

Trigger Keywords

performance evaluation, HR assessment, performance review, KPI setting, OKR, MBO, 360-degree evaluation, feedback interview, goal setting, performance management, salary negotiation, employee evaluation

Workflow

Step 1: Confirm organizational status and evaluation purpose

  • Organization size (startup / small and medium-sized enterprise / large corporation)
  • Current performance management method in use
  • Evaluation purpose:
    • Compensation linkage (salary increase, performance bonus)
    • Growth support (development, competency development)
    • Organizational goal alignment (sharing company-wide direction)

Step 2: Select a performance management framework

2026 trend: Parallel OKR + KPI

Category MBO KPI OKR
Focus Responsibility/compensation linkage Quantitative measurement Direction/alignment
Cycle Annual Continuous Quarterly
Compensation linkage Strong Present Principally separated
Transparency Low Medium High (company-wide disclosure)
Suitable organizations Hierarchical traditional companies Repetitive/stable work Startups/innovative organizations
Major adopters Public institutions, traditional large corporation industries All industries SK, Hanwha financial affiliates, startups

Recommended approach for 2026:

  • Startups / tech companies: Parallel OKR (quarterly) + KPI (continuous monitoring)
  • Small and medium-sized enterprises: Simplified MBO + 3-5 core KPIs
  • Traditional large corporation industries: MBO-based + consider introducing team-level OKR
  • Common: Trend of introducing AI-based performance data analysis

Step 3: Support OKR writing

OKR writing principles:

  • Objective: Qualitative, challenging, motivating (1-5)
    • Example: "Build an onboarding experience customers love"
  • Key Results: Measurable, time-bound (2-5 per objective)
    • Example: "Improve onboarding completion rate from 60% to 85% (3 months)"
    • Example: "Improve NPS score from 32 to 50"

OKR writing checklist:

  • Does the Objective inspire? (Not: "Achieved xx%")
  • Are Key Results measurable numerically?
  • Can achievement of the Objective be judged by whether the Key Results are achieved?
  • Is it a challenging goal achievable at 60-70%? (Stretch Goal)
  • Is it not directly tied to compensation? (OKR principle)

Step 4: Evaluation Design

Evaluation item composition:

성과 평가 (What: 목표 달성도) — 60~70% 비중
  - KPI/OKR Key Results 달성률
  - 목표 대비 실적 (정량)
  - 주요 프로젝트 기여도

역량 평가 (How: 행동 방식) — 30~40% 비중
  - 직무 역량 (업무 전문성)
  - 리더십/협업 역량
  - 성장 가능성 (잠재력)

360-degree evaluation design:

  • Upward evaluation: subordinate → manager (anonymity guaranteed)
  • Peer evaluation: peer → peer (focused on collaboration competency)
  • Self-evaluation: self → self (reflection and growth plan)
  • Evaluation items: 5-point scale + descriptive feedback

Step 5: Evaluation Interview (Calibration & Feedback)

Evaluation interview script (basic structure):

① 시작 (5분): 면담 목적과 분위기 설정
   "오늘은 지난 [기간] 동안의 성장과 다음 [기간] 계획을 함께 이야기해보려 해요."

② 자기 평가 확인 (10분):
   "스스로 가장 잘 해냈다고 생각하는 것은 무엇인가요?"
   "아쉬웠던 부분이나 더 잘할 수 있었던 점은?"

③ 관리자 피드백 (10분):
   - 긍정적 피드백: 구체적 행동 + 영향 + 감사
   - 개선 피드백: 관찰 사실 + 영향 + 기대 행동 (SBI 모델)

④ 다음 기간 목표 합의 (10분):
   OKR/KPI 초안 함께 검토

⑤ 지원 사항 확인 (5분):
   "제가 어떻게 지원해드리면 목표 달성에 도움이 될까요?"

SBI feedback model:

  • S (Situation): "In last week's client meeting"
  • B (Behavior): "When you presented without sufficiently reviewing the proposal"
  • I (Impact): "The client was confused, which delayed the contract decision"

Step 6: Calibration of Evaluation Results

Ensuring fairness:

  • Preventing leniency error: Provide evaluation distribution guidelines (e.g., setting S-A-B-C-D ratios)
  • Preventing recency effect: Evaluate based on data from the entire evaluation period
  • Bias check: Monitor bias based on protected characteristics such as gender, age, and nationality

Step 7: Generate Performance Evaluation Report

# [이름/팀] 성과평가 결과

## 종합 평가 등급: [S/A/B/C/D]

## KPI/OKR 달성 현황
| 목표 | 목표치 | 실적 | 달성률 |

## 강점 (계속 유지할 것)

## 개선 기회 (다음 기간 집중 사항)

## 다음 기간 목표 (합의)

## 성장을 위한 지원 계획

Deliverables

  • Performance evaluation framework design (tailored to OKR/MBO/KPI)
  • OKR/KPI objective draft
  • 360-degree evaluation survey questions
  • Evaluation interview script
  • Individual performance evaluation report
  • Team/organization performance dashboard

Related skills (chain)

Evaluation interview scripts, strengths/improvement opportunities in performance evaluation reports, feedback descriptions, etc. prose portionsare writing meant for humans to read, so immediately after drafting they go through the post-processing chain below.

Text post-processing chain (prose deliverables such as interview scripts and descriptive portions of evaluation reports):

performance-review → moai-core:ai-slop-reviewer → moai-content:humanize-korean
  • moai-core:ai-slop-reviewer — Review and revise AI-tic patterns (mechanical tone, clichéd feedback expressions)
  • moai-content:humanize-korean — Polish into natural Korean sentences (100% preservation of meaning)

Numeric/table deliverables such as KPI/OKR achievement rate tables, evaluation grade matrices, and performance dashboards numeric/table deliverablesare not subject to the above text chain. If you need tables or dashboards, route to moai-office:xlsx-creator or moai-data:data-visualizer. For mixed deliverables, apply the chain only to the descriptive portions and keep data routing for tables.

Notes

2026 Performance Management Trends

  • Surge in companies adopting OKRs: SK and Hanwha financial affiliates leading, standardization across the startup industry
  • Adoption of AI performance analysis: Data-driven goal setting and tracking is the new standard
  • OKR + KPI in parallel: Running both in parallel rather than choosing a single method is the mainstream in 2026
  • Millennials/Gen Z: 80% view AI work efficiency positively, prefer real-time feedback

Precautions for Compliance with the Labor Standards Act

  • Prohibition of dismissal or forced retirement demands based on unfair performance evaluations
  • Evaluation results must follow the evaluation criteria agreed upon in the employment contract
  • Personal Information Protection Act applies when disclosing evaluation results
  • Confirm salary negotiation results in writing (clarification of working conditions)

Problem Solving

  • Uncertainty about Labor Standards Act provisions: Evaluations involving unfair dismissal, demotion, or wage reduction require review by a labor attorney. Legal content provided by AI is for reference only.
  • Insufficient information on job grade system: If you provide the team size, job category classification, and existing evaluation method, a more customized evaluation system can be designed.
  • Concern about evaluation bias: If there is concern about subjective evaluation of a specific employee, it is recommended to design an anonymous 360-degree evaluation and conduct calibration sessions.
  • Inability to measure OKR achievement rate: For roles without quantitative metrics (creative roles, support departments), design the evaluation to increase the weight of descriptive evaluation + peer feedback.

When not to use this skill

  • Responding to legal labor disputes: Refer dismissal, disciplinary action, and wage disputes resulting from evaluation results to a labor attorney.
  • Recruitment and onboarding process: JD writing, interview design, and new employee onboarding are better suited to the moai-hr:employment-manager skill.
  • Offer letter and salary negotiation documents: moai-hr:draft-offer skill.
  • Establishing remote work policy: For work-from-home policy and collaboration tool selection, use the moai-hr:people-operations skill.