SuperAPI AI Directory

legal-contract-review

General & other

View repository

Updated 10-15 21:02

About this skill

Contract Review

Overview

Supports contract review and legal document drafting. Provides analysis of 10 major risk patterns in contracts under Korean Civil and Commercial Law, drafting of terms of service, privacy policies, and SLAs, reflection of the 2026 amended Personal Information Protection Act, and recommendations for revising unfavorable clauses.

Disclaimer: This is AI-assisted analysis and does not replace professional legal advice

Trigger Keywords

contract, contract review, risky clauses, terms of service, privacy policy, SLA, civil law, commercial law, legal documents, service agreement, supply agreement, partnership agreement, memorandum of agreement

Workflow

Step 1: Identify the Request Type

Task Type:

  • Contract Review: Analysis of risky clauses in existing contracts and revision recommendations
  • Legal Document Drafting: New drafting of terms of service, privacy policies, SLAs, etc.

Document Type:

  • Service Agreement (SI, development outsourcing, consulting)
  • Supply Agreement (products, software licenses)
  • NDA (Non-Disclosure Agreement)
  • Partnership and Alliance Agreements
  • Employment and Service Delegation Agreements (employment contracts, freelancer delegation and independent contractor agreements)
  • Terms of Service, Privacy Policy, SLA

Employment and Service Delegation Agreement Risk Check (Additional Inspection Items):

  • Probation Clause: Whether the probation period and extension conditions are specified; dismissal during probation also requires just cause under Article 23 of the Labor Standards Act (probation of 3 months or less is exempt from dismissal notice — Article 26 proviso)
  • Comprehensive Wage Clause: A comprehensive wage agreement that lumps together overtime, night, and holiday allowances is valid only in limited cases, such as when calculating working hours is difficult (Supreme Court precedent) — if it falls short of actual working hours, there is a risk of unpaid wages
  • Non-Compete Clause: If the period, region, or scope of occupation is excessive, it may be judged invalid (Article 103 of the Civil Code, balancing the constitutional freedom to choose one's occupation and interests) — the existence of consideration (compensation) is the key issue
  • Disguised Freelancer Risk: If the form is a service contract (delegation or independent contractor) but the substance is a subordinate employment relationship, the person is judged to be an employee — even under a 3.3% contract, there is a retroactive risk of the four major insurances and severance pay
  • Boundary: Legal review of contract clauses is this skill, hiring practices (offers, JDs, onboarding) are moai-recruiter Use the skill line.

Confirm whether Korean law or foreign law applies

Mask input personal information: If the original contract contains personal information such as resident registration numbers, bank accounts, or contact details, moai-coworker:ai-slop-reviewer의 references/kr-pii-masking.md Masking is performed according to the rules before proceeding with the review (do not re-output the original in the review report).

Step 2: Contract Review (Top 10 Risks Checklist)

① Accuracy of Contracting Party Information

  • Verify company name, business registration number, representative, and address
  • Scope of authority of the contracting party (verify representative director/agent)

② Clarity of Contract Purpose and Scope

  • Are the subject and scope of the services/supply specific?
  • Are the deliverables specifications (Deliverables) stated?

③ Payment, Payment Terms, and Late Interest

  • Payment schedule for down payment, interim payment, and balance
  • Payment conditions (e.g., payment after inspection/approval)
  • Late interest rate (recommended within the statutory maximum interest rate of 20% per annum)

④ Delivery, Performance Conditions, and Penalty Clauses

  • Is the delivery/completion deadline clear?
  • Is the penalty (liquidated damages) reasonable in case of delay?
  • Whether a Force Majeure clause is included

⑤ Ownership of Intellectual Property Rights

  • Ownership of intellectual property rights (patents, copyrights, trade secrets) in the deliverables
  • Distinction between pre-existing IP and new IP
  • License scope (exclusive/non-exclusive)

⑥ Confidentiality Clause

  • Definition and scope of confidential information
  • Duration of confidentiality obligation (general: 2-5 years, trade secrets: may be permanent)
  • Exceptions (publicly known information, independent development, third-party acquisition, legal disclosure)

⑦ Scope and Limitation of Damages

  • Direct damages vs indirect damages (special damages)
  • Setting a cap on damages (e.g., 100% of the total contract amount)
  • Special provisions (indemnity clauses)

⑧ Contract Termination Conditions and Effects

  • Prior notice period for termination (typically 30 days)
  • Grounds for termination (matters, mutual termination rights)
  • Effects of termination (cost settlement, return of deliverables)

⑨ Dispute Resolution (Jurisdiction, Governing Law, Arbitration)

  • Agreed court of jurisdiction (recommended: the court at the location of one of the parties)
  • Governing law (recommended to specify application of Korean law)
  • Mediation/arbitration clause (optional)

⑩ Unfair Clauses (Potential Violation of the Act on Regulation of Terms and Conditions)

  • Clauses unfairly disadvantageous to the customer
  • Clauses restricting the customer's rights
  • Excessive limitation of indemnity clauses

Step 3: Drafting Legal Documents (Optional)

Terms of Use:

  • Compliance with the Electronic Commerce Act and Consumer Protection Act
  • Required inclusions:
    • How to use the service and terms of use
    • Usage fees and payment methods
    • Restrictions on use and termination procedures
    • Limitation of liability (indemnity clauses)
    • Dispute resolution (jurisdiction, etc.)

Privacy Policy:

  • Reflecting the Personal Information Protection Act (amended on September 11, 2026)
  • Required inclusions:
    • Items collected (required/optional)
    • Purpose of use
    • Retention period
    • Provision to third parties (whether provided, recipients, purpose)
    • Destruction methods and procedures
    • Rights of data subjects (access, correction, deletion)
    • Whether cookies are used

SLA (Service Level Agreement):

  • Availability target (e.g., 99.9% uptime)
  • Response time by incident severity (P1/P2/P3)
  • Remedy for breach (service credits, penalty)
  • Monitoring and reporting method

Step 4: Present recommended amendments

Flag risk clauses and suggest alternative wording:

  • 🔴 Immediate amendment recommended: Clauses clearly legally disadvantageous
  • 🟡 Negotiation recommended: Clauses open to agreement
  • 🟢 Acceptable: Clauses at a standard level

Negotiation point priorities:

  1. Intellectual property ownership (ownership of deliverables IP)
  2. Limitation of liability (prevent unlimited liability)
  3. Contract termination conditions (prevent disadvantageous termination)
  4. Governing court (prevent distant courts)

Usage examples

Example 1: "Review this IT service contract. We are Party A. [contract contents]" → Top 10 risk check → Flag disadvantageous clauses → Recommended amendments → Negotiation points

Example 2: "Create SaaS service terms and a privacy policy" → Confirm service scope → Draft terms of service → Draft privacy policy → Review

Example 3: "Draft an API partnership agreement" → Confirm partnership terms → Draft agreement → Explain key clauses

Deliverables

  • Contract review report (top 10 risk analysis)
  • Recommended amendments by clause
  • Prioritized list of negotiation points
  • Drafts of terms of service, privacy policy, and SLA
  • Contract drafting guide

Precautions

Disclaimer: This is AI-assisted analysis and does not replace professional legal advice

Precautions when reviewing contracts:

  • Must review before signing (post-signing amendments are difficult)
  • Explain professional legal terms in plain Korean
  • For complex contracts (joint ventures, M&A, etc.), consulting a law firm is recommended

Precautions when drafting legal documents:

  • Comply with relevant laws such as the Act on Consumer Protection in Electronic Commerce, Consumer Protection Act, and Personal Information Protection Act
  • Prevent clauses that violate the Act on the Regulation of Terms and Conditions (Terms and Conditions Act)

Related skills

  • moai-lawyer:legal-nda-triage: Specialized review of NDA confidentiality agreements
  • moai-lawyer:legal-compliance-check: Regulatory compliance checks, ESG reporting
  • moai-lawyer:legal-legal-risk: Legal risk analysis, intellectual property strategy
  • moai-coworker:ai-slop-reviewer: AI pattern review of contract drafts and recommended amendments

Post-processing chain (text deliverables)

Descriptive deliverables such as contract drafts, recommended amendments, terms of service, privacy policies, and SLAs must always be finalized through the following chain after drafting.

legal-contract-review → moai-coworker:ai-slop-reviewer → moai-writer:korean-humanize → 최종 검수
> **정형 서식 보호** — 이 스킬의 산출물은 정형 문서다. 슬롭 검수는 금지어 치환만 수행하고, 구조(개조식·항목 번호 체계·두문/본문/결문)는 재작성하지 않는다.
  • moai-coworker:ai-slop-reviewer: Review for AI writing patterns (exaggeration, clichés, uniform structure)
  • moai-writer:korean-humanize: Polish into sentences that read as if written by a person by correcting Korean naturalness

When not to use this skill

  • Specialized review of NDA confidentiality agreements → use moai-lawyer:legal-nda-triage
  • Compliance audits or ESG reporting → use moai-lawyer:legal-compliance-check
  • Legal risk analysis or intellectual property strategy → use moai-lawyer:legal-legal-risk
  • Actual legal disputes or litigation response → be sure to engage a professional lawyer

References

File Load conditions
references/contract/guide.md When detailed contract review guides and risk clause assessment criteria are needed
references/service-legal-docs.md When drafting service legal documents such as terms of service, privacy policies, and claim responses