SuperAPI AI Directory

feedback-loop

General & other

View repository

Updated 10-15 21:37

About this skill

Giving and Receiving Feedback (Feedback Loop)

Overview

Feedback is hard. The giver, afraid of damaging the relationship, speaks in circles and the message gets blurred, while the receiver takes it as a personal attack and goes straight to defending themselves. This skill provides a structure (SBI) that anchors feedback to behavior and issues, not the person, and helps you separate emotion from fact in received feedback so you keep only what's worth learning from. Without avoiding it, and without breaking.

Trigger Keywords

feedback, how to give feedback, receiving feedback, negative feedback, constructive feedback, harsh criticism, avoiding feedback, interim report, interim feedback, SBI, digesting feedback

Workflow

Step 1: Define the purpose of the feedback

Criticism and feedback are different. Feedback is helping the other person do better, not venting anger.

  • Before giving it, ask yourself: "What do I want the other person to change with these words?" If there's no answer, that's just emotional dumping.
  • When receiving it, the premise: "Is there even one piece in here that I can use?"
  • Praise feedback should be just as specific — instead of "good job," say "what was good and why"

Step 2: Deliver using the SBI structure (giver's side)

It's a three-part structure that detaches behavior from the person.

Step Content Example
S (Situation) When and where "At yesterday's client meeting"
B (Behavior) Observed facts (without interpretation) "During the presentation, the materials weren't shown in advance, so it was delayed by 5 minutes"
I (Impact) The result that behavior had "I think the client felt it was underprepared"

→ Character attacks or generalizations like "You're always unprepared" are forbidden. State only fact → impact, and find improvements together.

Step 3: Digest received feedback (receiver's side)

When negative feedback comes, the instinct is to defend. Put one beat in between.

  1. Pause instead of replying immediately: buy time with "Thanks for the feedback, I'll organize it and get back to you"
  2. Separate emotion ↔ fact: whether it feels bad and whether the content is true are viewed separately
  3. Keep just one thing: it doesn't all have to be right. Pick just one usable piece and turn it into action
  4. Weight the source: weigh feedback from people you trust and repeated feedback heavily, and one-off or malicious feedback lightly

→ Feedback is not a final verdict on me, but one perspective at one point in time.

Step 4: Ask for feedback first

Don't wait for feedback—ask for it first so you can receive it in small, frequent doses (interim updates).

  • Ask specifically: Instead of "How was it?" (vague), ask "Is there any part of this report where the logic is weak?"
  • Pick the timing: At the draft stage before completion — it's easier to fix than after it's all done
  • "I'm working on it" signal: Sharing progress along the way builds trust and prevents last-minute mishaps

Step 5: Close the feedback loop with action

Once you receive it, you have to close the loop so the next feedback comes.

  • Among the feedback you received, 1–2 things to change—decide and actually apply them
  • To the person who gave the feedback, briefly share the results of acting on it — "I took what you said last time and changed it like this"
  • This closing loop builds the trust that "this person is someone who receives feedback"

Usage examples

Example 1: "My junior keeps missing deadlines—how should I say it so it doesn't hurt their feelings?" → SBI structure (Situation·Behavior·Impact) → remove personal characterizations → end with a question that seeks an improvement plan together

Example 2: "I got feedback from my boss that I'm not good at my job and I'm so upset" → Separate emotions from facts → judge whether it's repeated and whether the source is trustworthy, and weight it → one usable piece + an action conversion plan

Example 3: "I want to get feedback early in the middle of a project—how do I ask for it?" → Design specific questions → timing at the draft stage → interim update message template

Deliverables

  • SBI-based feedback script (Situation·Behavior·Impact)
  • Checklist for digesting received feedback (separating emotions/facts · weighting)
  • Feedback request questions + interim update message template
  • Message for sharing the results of acting on it

Precautions

  • Give negative feedback 1:1, immediately, and briefly. Criticism in a public setting lingers as an insult rather than a message.
  • You don't have to accept all the feedback you receive. However, repeated feedback is likely a signal.
  • If you try to soften feedback with "beating around the bush" and the core disappears, it's the same as not giving it at all.

Related skills

  • moai-comms:negotiation-1on1: Conversation design when feedback leads to an interview or request
  • moai-comms:report-speak: Receiving feedback in advance through interim updates
  • moai-comms:conflict-handler: Responding when feedback escalates into conflict
  • moai-hr:performance-review: Formal performance evaluation feedback interview

When not to use this skill

  • Formal HR evaluation·performance review feedback: For evaluation interviews, use moai-hr:performance-review.
  • Personal reflection·self-check: For reflection you do alone, use moai-productivity.
  • Harassment·discrimination situations: If it's not simple feedback but workplace harassment, handle it through HR/grievance channels and formal procedures.

Source

General feedback framework (SBI model, separating emotion/facts, interim reporting) + reference to user vault notes. Wording and examples are independently composed based on South Korea as of 2026.