This is Elon Musk's First Principles-based 5-step problem-solving algorithm.
Core Principles
Order is everything: Verify requirements -> Delete -> Optimize -> Accelerate -> Automate "Optimizing something that shouldn't exist" is the most common mistake.
5-Step Algorithm
Step 1: Question the requirements
"Make the requirements less dumb."
- Requirements are always somewhat dumb
- Question the requirements no matter how smart the person who gave them is
- If you don't start here, a perfect answer to the wrong questionis what you'll get
Question:
- Why does this requirement exist?
- Who requested this? For what reason?
- Can the goal be achieved without this requirement?
Step 2: Try deleting
"If you're not forced to put back at least 10% of what you delete, you're not deleting enough."
- Try completely deletingparts, features, and process steps
- If you had to restore more than 10% of what you deleted, you deleted enough
- Most people delete too conservativelyDelete with
Question:
- What happens if you completely remove this?
- Can the core goal be achieved without it?
- Are you following the 10% rule?
Step 3: Optimize or simplify
"The most common mistake of smart engineers is to optimize a thing that should not exist."
- After trying deletion , you should optimize
- Optimizing something that shouldn't exist is the most common mistake
- The smarter a person is, the more easily they fall into this trap
Question:
- Among what remains, what can be simplified?
- How can complexity be reduced?
- Is there a simpler alternative?
Step 4: Increase speed
"Any given thing can be done faster than you think."
- Anything can be done faster than you think
- But after deletion and optimization , you should increase speed
Question:
- Where is the bottleneck?
- How can cycle time be reduced?
- Is parallel processing possible?
Step 5: Automate
"And then the fifth thing is to automate it."
- Automation is the last step
- It is worth automating only after going through the above steps
Question:
- What are the repetitive tasks?
- Is the ROI of automation sufficient?
- Does automation not increase the maintenance burden?
Analysis Output Format
## 문제 분석: [문제명]
### 현재 상태
- **문제**: [현재 문제 설명]
- **영향**: [문제로 인한 영향]
### Step 1: 요구사항 검증
| 요구사항 | 출처 | 타당성 | 판정 |
|----------|------|--------|------|
| [요구사항] | [누가 요청] | [검토 결과] | 유지/수정/제거 |
**결론**: [요구사항 검토 요약]
### Step 2: 삭제 분석
| 대상 | 삭제 시 영향 | 판정 |
|------|-------------|------|
| [기능/부품/단계] | [영향 분석] | 삭제/유지 |
**삭제 목록**: [삭제할 항목]
**10% 규칙 체크**: [충분히 과감했는가?]
### Step 3: 최적화 제안
| 대상 | 현재 상태 | 개선안 |
|------|----------|--------|
| [남은 항목] | [현재] | [단순화 방안] |
### Step 4: 가속화 방안
| 병목 | 현재 소요 | 개선 후 | 방법 |
|------|----------|---------|------|
| [병목 지점] | [현재 시간] | [목표 시간] | [방법] |
### Step 5: 자동화 대상
| 작업 | 빈도 | 자동화 방법 | ROI |
|------|------|------------|-----|
| [반복 작업] | [빈도] | [방법] | [투자 대비 효과] |
### 최종 권고
1. **즉시 실행**: [바로 할 수 있는 것]
2. **단기 개선**: [1-2주 내]
3. **장기 개선**: [1개월 이상]
### 예상 효과
- **효율성**: [X% 개선]
- **비용**: [X% 절감]
- **시간**: [X% 단축]
Examples of Application by Domain
Software Development
| Step | Question |
|---|---|
| Requirements | Is this feature really necessary? |
| Delete | Can this code/module be removed? |
| Optimize | Can the remaining code be simplified? |
| Accelerate | Can performance be improved? |
| Automate | Can it be automated with CI/CD? |
Business Process
| Step | Question |
|---|---|
| Requirements | Why is this approval step necessary? |
| Delete | Can this meeting/report be eliminated? |
| Optimize | Can the remaining process be simplified? |
| Accelerate | Can decision-making time be reduced? |
| Automate | Is workflow automation possible? |
Checklist
Check before completing the analysis:
- Have you verified the source and reason for every requirement?
- Have you deleted boldly enough to roll back 10% or more?
- Did you proceed with optimization after deletion? (Follow the order)
- Did you consider automation last?
- Did you proceed through each step in order?
Common Mistakes
| Mistake | Why It Is a Problem | Correct Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Optimizing Immediately | Improving unnecessary things | Try deleting first |
| Automating Immediately | Automating a flawed process | Follow the 5-step order |
| Conservative Deletion | Not achieving sufficient improvement | Apply the 10% rule |
| Accepting Requirements | Solving the wrong problem | Always start by questioning |