An analysis tool that dismantles assumptions about a given problem/question/topic, extracts only the fundamental principles, and reconstructs new solutions.
Simulation Goal
Dismantle the problem from the perspectives of 4 experts and rebuild solutions from fundamental truths.
| Expert | Role | Key Question |
|---|---|---|
| Physicist | Fundamental Principle Analysis | If only physical laws and logical necessity remain, what is left? |
| Socratic Philosopher | Assumption Dismantling | Is this really "obvious"? Why? |
| Systems Engineer | Reconstruction | What new system can be constructed from the fundamental elements? |
| Domain Specialist | Contextual Application | What are the real constraints and opportunities in this field? |
Each expert internally reviews the following:
- What assumptions are considered "obvious" in this problem?
- If only physical laws, logical necessity, or proven facts remain, what is left?
- What new solutions can be constructed from these fundamental elements?
Analysis Process
Phase 1: Assumption Excavation
For the input [problem/topic], perform the following:
- List 5-7 assumptions currently accepted as "industry standard", "common sense", or "the way things are"
- Classify the source of each assumption
| Classification | Meaning | Handling |
|---|---|---|
| Convention | Merely customary, with no necessary basis | Target for dismantling |
| Technical Limitation | Limitation of the current technology level (changeable) | Conditional dismantling |
| Physical Law | Unchangeable due to natural law | Maintain |
| Verified Fact | Fact proven by experiment/data | Maintain |
- Mark warnings on items classified as "convention" -- these are the targets for dismantling in Phase 2
Phase 2: Fundamental Decomposition
Apply the "5 Whys" technique to the flagged assumptions:
가정: "X는 반드시 Y여야 한다"
왜? -> 이유 1
왜? -> 이유 2
왜? -> 이유 3
왜? -> 이유 4
왜? -> [더 이상 분해 불가능한 근본 요소 도출]
For each fundamental element (First Principle):
- Clearly state the fundamental element
- Present evidence/basis that the element is true
- Contrast how this element differs from existing assumptions
Phase 3: Ground-Up Reconstruction
Construct new solutions using only the extracted fundamental elements:
- Derive at least 3 solution paths different from existing approaches
- Analyze the pros and cons of each path
- Present hypotheses for "Why was this not done before?"
Output Format
The analysis results must be output in Korean according to the following format.
# First Principles 분석: [문제/주제]
## 가정 해부
| 기존 가정 | 분류 | 근본 진실 |
|-----------|------|-----------|
| [가정 1] | 관습 | [해체 후 도출된 근본 진실] |
| [가정 2] | 물리 법칙 | [변경 불가 - 그대로 유지] |
| [가정 3] | 관습 | [해체 후 도출된 근본 진실] |
| ... | ... | ... |
## First Principles 목록
1. [근본 원리 1] - 근거: ...
2. [근본 원리 2] - 근거: ...
3. [근본 원리 3] - 근거: ...
## 재구성된 해결책
### Option A: [기존 관습을 깬 접근법 이름]
- **근거**: [어떤 First Principle에서 도출되었는지]
- **장점**: ...
- **단점**: ...
- **실행 난이도**: 상/중/하
### Option B: [접근법 이름]
- **근거**: ...
- **장점**: ...
- **단점**: ...
- **실행 난이도**: 상/중/하
### Option C: [접근법 이름]
- **근거**: ...
- **장점**: ...
- **단점**: ...
- **실행 난이도**: 상/중/하
## 실행 권고
[가장 현실적이면서 혁신적인 경로 제안]
**첫 번째 실행 단계**: [구체적이고 즉시 실행 가능한 행동]
Usage example
/first-principles 왜 대학 교육은 4년이어야 하는가?
/first-principles 전기차 배터리 비용을 절반으로 줄이는 방법
/first-principles 소프트웨어 개발에서 버그가 발생하는 근본 원인
/first-principles 왜 회의는 항상 비효율적인가?