never-issue-shares

Do not use stock for acquisitions

R — Original text (Reading)

"I would rather have prepared for a colonoscopy than issued Berkshire shares." (2016, on the Dexter Shoe mistake)

I — Methodology skeleton

Acquiring with your own stock = giving up the power of future compounding:

• Stock is not "free money" — what you give up is the compound returns from holding an excellent business
• Dexter Shoe: acquired with $434 million of Berkshire stock; that stock later became worth $6 billion+, while Dexter went to zero
• General Re: issued 272,200 shares = 21.8% dilution — equivalent to giving away 1/5 of the company for free
• "Cashless transaction" is the most dangerous phrase — stock payment has enormous hidden costs

A1 — Application in the book

Case: Dexter Shoe

• Problem: In 1993, acquired Dexter Shoe with 4,309 shares of Berkshire stock ($434 million)
• Use: A typical mistake of acquiring with stock — selling a "golden asset" worth $6 billion+ in the future in exchange for a business that went to zero
• Result: Buffett called it a "mistake of historic proportions" — if cash had been used for the acquisition, the loss would have been only $434 million rather than $6 billion

Case: General Re

• Use: In 1998, acquired General Re with 272,200 shares of Berkshire stock
• Result: 21.8% dilution — Buffett later admitted that using cash would have been better

A2 — Trigger scenarios

1. The company is considering acquiring another company with stock
2. Evaluating the payment method in an acquisition plan
3. Analyzing the impact of equity dilution on existing shareholders
4. Understanding why some CEOs prefer "cashless transactions"

Language signals

• "Doesn't acquiring with stock mean you don't have to spend money?"
• "Is the equity dilution severe?"
• "Which is better, cash acquisition or stock acquisition?"
• "Why does Buffett regret acquiring with stock?"

Distinction from adjacent skills

• With first-law-of-capital-allocation distinction: the first law is about the use of retained earnings; this skill is about the payment method for acquisitions

E — Executable steps

1. Calculate the "hidden cost"

   • Completion standard: assuming the acquired business goes to zero, how much will the stock you issued be worth in 30 years? That number is the true cost

2. Do the "cash test"

   • Completion standard: if you had enough cash, would you still choose to pay with stock? If not → you should not use stock

3. Evaluate the quality of the acquiree

   • Completion standard: is the acquired business better than your own business? If not → never use stock

B — Boundaries

• In very rare cases (both businesses are extremely excellent and reasonably valued), a stock acquisition may be acceptable
• Small companies may be forced to use stock when they cannot obtain sufficient cash financing — this is a financing constraint rather than a choice
• Author's blind spot: Berkshire's stock price was extremely undervalued for a long time — stock-swap acquisitions were especially expensive for Buffett; other companies' situations may differ

---

Related skills (Stage 3 fill-in)

• composes-with: first-law-of-capital-allocation, compounding-thinking

Audit information

• Verification passed: V1 ✓ / V2 ✓ / V3 ✓
• Distillation time: 2026-04-16