spec-impl

Spec Implement

Task-by-task implementer that reads a completed specification and executes each task atomically. Reads docs/features/<feature-name>/ files produced by /spec-create.

Input

/spec-impl <feature-name>

• feature-name: required — must match an existing directory under docs/features/

When to Use

• A feature spec exists (requirements, design, tasks) and you're ready to implement
• Resuming implementation after a session interruption

Not this skill: To create or update a spec, use spec-create. To implement a single task test-first, use tdd.

Role

You are a spec-driven implementer. You execute tasks from a completed specification one-by-one, ensuring traceability and test coverage.

Workflow

1. Initialize

1. Verify docs/features/<feature-name>/ exists
2. Read all 3 spec files for full context:
   • docs/features/<feature-name>/requirements.md
   • docs/features/<feature-name>/design.md
   • docs/features/<feature-name>/tasks.md
3. Load references/verify-by-language.md now — identify the project's ecosystem and test runner from project files using the detection table. Do this once at init, not on first verify command encounter.
4. Handle edge cases (see Edge Cases below)

2. Pick Next Task

Scan tasks.md for the next task to execute:

1. Read all ### T-X headings
2. For each, read its **Status**: and **Blocked by**: fields (match by **Label**: prefix, not line position)
3. A task is unblocked when it has no Blocked by field, or all tasks listed in Blocked by have **Status**: Complete
4. Select the first unblocked task (by document order) with status Not Started or In Progress — document order provides determinism; Blocked by fields determine what is eligible, document order determines which eligible task is picked
5. If resuming a session, reconstruct state from tasks.md — never rely on chat history

3. Restate Before Coding

Before touching any code, restate:

• Goal: what this task achieves (from task title + Refs)
• Key files: files to create or modify (from Files field)
• Rules: business rules this task enforces (from Rules field, if any)
• Verify: the exact command that will prove completion

Set **Status**: In Progress in tasks.md.

4. Design Sufficiency Check

Check whether design.md provides enough detail for this task. This is required when:

• The task references a TD-X not yet validated by a previous task, or
• The task creates files in a directory not yet touched by any completed task

Skip if a previous task already validated the same TD-X references and directory.

If the design is ambiguous, incomplete, or needs updating:

• Stop immediately — do not guess or improvise
• Inform the user what is missing or unclear
• Ask the user to update the design before continuing
• Do not resume implementation until the design gap is resolved

5. Implement

• Write the code following design decisions from design.md
• Is the Verify command a test runner? A command is a test runner if it invokes: jest, vitest, mocha, pytest, cargo test, go test, mix test, dart test, flutter test, mvn test, ./gradlew test, node --test, or project scripts that delegate to these. If yes, follow the tdd skill's red-green-refactor cycle: write the failing test first, then implement until it passes. If the Verify command is NOT a test runner (e.g., tsc --noEmit, cargo clippy, npm run build, a migration command, a shell health-check script), implement the code directly and proceed to validation — TDD does not apply.
• Test files implied by the Verify command are always in scope, even if not explicitly listed in the task's Files field — the Files field is guidance for what to touch, not an exhaustive allowlist
• If implementation requires touching a file not in the task's Files field but listed in design.md's File Inventory (e.g., adding an import to an index file), proceed — File Inventory is the broader source of truth. If the file is not in the File Inventory at all, inform the user before modifying it
• If implementation requires a new dependency referenced in design.md (e.g., a library choice in a TD-X), install it as part of the task. If the dependency is NOT mentioned in design.md, treat it as a design gap — stop and ask the user before installing

6. Validate

Run the exact Verify command from the task. Do not substitute a different command.

• Exit code 0 → verification passed, proceed to step 7
• Exit code non-zero → verification failed:
  1. Read the error output, diagnose the failure
  2. Distinguish between a code failure (test assertion fails, logic bug) and a command failure (file not found, test runner not installed, grep pattern matches nothing, syntax error in the command itself)
  3. Code failure: fix the code (not the test, unless the test itself is wrong), re-run the same Verify command
  4. Command failure: the Verify command itself is likely wrong (spec-create writes these before code exists — they are predictions). Inform the user that the command appears incorrect, explain what's wrong, and suggest a corrected command. Do not silently update the Verify field — get user confirmation first, then update tasks.md
  5. Repeat until exit code 0 or you're stuck — if stuck, inform the user with the error output and ask for guidance

A task stays In Progress until verification passes. Never mark Complete on a failing verify.

7. Update tasks.md

• Set **Status**: Complete
• Append a **Result**: field — state what was implemented and the test outcome in one line (e.g., "AuthService with login/logout — 6 passing tests" or "DB migration applied — schema test passing")
• Inform the user that the task is ready for review and commit

You may batch up to 3 consecutive tasks that share the same Phase heading before pausing for user review. Always pause after tasks that introduce new architectural patterns or touch shared state.

Exception — Phase 0 [INFRA] tasks: Infrastructure tasks (event store setup, dispatcher config, migrations with no business logic) have no TDD cycle and no user-facing behavior to review incrementally. Batch all Phase 0 tasks together without pausing, then present the full infrastructure setup for a single review before moving to Phase 1.

8. Repeat

Go back to step 2. Pick the next unblocked task.

9. Completion

When all tasks are done:

• Summarize what was implemented
• List any issues encountered and how they were resolved

Reference Guide

Topic	Reference	Load When
Implementation do & don't	references/do-dont-impl.md	Executing tasks — need concrete good/bad examples
Verify commands by language	references/verify-by-language.md	Writing or running verify commands — need language-specific patterns

Edge Cases

Edge Case	Behavior
docs/features/<name>/ doesn't exist	List existing feature dirs under docs/features/, suggest closest match. If none exist: "No specs found. Run /spec-create <name> first."
tasks.md missing but requirements/design exist	Error: "Spec incomplete — tasks.md missing. Complete spec with /spec-create <name>."
Design insufficient for current task	Stop implementation. Inform user what is missing. Ask user to update design via plan mode before continuing.
All tasks already Complete	Inform user, ask if they want to add new tasks or review
New work discovered during implementation	Ask user to confirm, then add to tasks.md — never work on unlisted tasks
Task blocked by unresolved dependency	Skip to next unblocked task, inform user
Verify command is wrong	Inform user what's wrong, suggest correction, update tasks.md after user confirms
Task needs unlisted dependency	If dependency is in design.md, install it. If not, treat as design gap — ask user
Task needs file not in its Files field	If file is in File Inventory, proceed. If not in File Inventory, inform user
Session interrupted mid-task	On resume, read tasks.md to find in-progress task, continue from there
Multiple tasks In Progress on resume	Pick the first by document order. Complete it before moving to the next In Progress task

Test Quality

Test Types

Type	Scope	When to Use	Characteristics
Unit	Single function/class in isolation	Default for service logic, utilities, pure functions	Mock all dependencies (DB, APIs, other services). Fast, deterministic.
Integration	Multiple components working together	When a task wires components (routes → service → DB)	Use real dependencies where practical (test DB, in-memory stores). Verify contracts between layers.
E2E	Full user flow through the system	Final tasks that validate complete features	Run the actual application. Test from the user's entry point (HTTP request, CLI command, UI action). Slower, use sparingly.

Choosing the Right Type

• Task creates a service/utility with mocked deps → unit
• Task wires components together (routes → service → DB) → integration
• Task validates a complete user-facing flow → e2e
• Migration + schema assertion → integration

For language-specific verify command patterns, see references/verify-by-language.md.

Quality Rules

• Tests must cover business rules and edge cases, not just the happy path
• No flaky tests: deterministic, no timing dependencies, no external service calls without mocks
• Unit tests mock dependencies — if your test hits a real database, it's integration
• Integration tests verify component boundaries — if everything is mocked, it's a unit test
• E2E tests validate what the user sees — don't test internal implementation details at this level

Constraints

MUST DO

• Read all 3 spec files at start for full context
• Verify design sufficiency when a task references an unvalidated TD-X or creates files in an untouched directory
• Ensure all work is tracked in tasks.md — no unlisted work
• Restate task goal, files, rules, and verify command before coding
• Set **Status**: In Progress before starting implementation
• Run the exact Verify command from the task — a task is not done until exit code 0
• On verification failure: diagnose, fix, re-run — never mark Complete on a failing verify
• If the Verify command itself is broken (not a code failure), inform user and get confirmation before updating it
• Update tasks.md after each task with **Status**: Complete and a **Result**: field
• Inform user after task completion so they can review and commit

MUST NOT DO

• Mark a task as Complete without exit code 0 from its Verify command
• Substitute a different verification command without user confirmation (if the command is broken, propose a fix and get approval)
• Skip tasks or work out of order (unless blocked)
• Work on tasks not listed in tasks.md
• Start a task whose Blocked by dependencies are not all Complete
• Rely on chat history — always reconstruct from files
• Improvise when design is ambiguous — always stop and ask for clarification

Related Skills

• spec-create — Creates the spec that spec-impl executes
• tdd — When a task's Verify command is a test runner, use tdd's red-green-refactor cycle: write the failing test first, then implement until it passes