Stress-test one proposal until its important decisions, assumptions, dependencies, failure modes, and verification are explicit.
Start from evidence
Read the supplied proposal and its declared sources. Inspect code, tests, schemas, configuration, and documentation before asking for facts the repository can answer.
Build a small decision tree around the goal, users, constraints, ownership, boundaries, data flow, failure behavior, compatibility, rollout, reversibility, and proof. Follow only branches that can change the proposal.
Interview loop
- Ask exactly one consequential question.
- Include the answer you recommend from current evidence.
- Label an answer as an assumption when evidence is missing.
- State why the decision matters.
- Challenge vague scope, hidden assumptions, premature abstractions, and weak verification.
- Resolve the current decision before moving to a dependent one.
- Stop when the proposal is coherent, a required fact is unavailable, or the user asks to stop.
Use this shape:
Question: <one focused question>
Recommended answer: <the answer and any assumption>
Why it matters: <the decision or risk>
Do not turn the interview into a generic checklist. Do not ask the user to rediscover repository facts.
Paper trail
Read grill log guidance only when a log path is known or the user requests persistence.
Return decisions in conversation by default. When persistence is requested, use the supplied path, a location beside a referenced artifact, or ~/.engineering-workflow/<project-or-subject>/grills/. Saving a log requires no work-item setup or companion artifacts. Do not block the interview on storage.
Record material decisions and changed assumptions. Do not record every turn, a transcript, hidden reasoning, full source content, or repeated instructions.
This skill is read-only except for an authorized grill log. It does not authorize specifications, plans, tickets, code changes, commits, or publication.
Finish
Return:
- resolved decisions and rationale
- changed assumptions
- remaining risks or unknowns
- recommended changes to the proposal