Purpose
The competition-law cease-and-desist letter under § 13 UWG is the gateway to injunction proceedings and a prerequisite for reimbursement of expenses (§ 13 III). It is effective only if standing to sue, formal requirements and a substantive infringement of the UWG coincide — and it must not be an abuse of rights within the meaning of § 8c UWG. This skill examines both sides: the sender (effectiveness, cost reimbursement, contractual penalty) and the recipient (defence strategy, modified cease-and-desist declaration, negative declaratory action).
Inputs
- Cease-and-desist letter (wording of the complaint, required cease-and-desist declaration, required reimbursement of expenses, deadline)
- Sender: competitor or association (with register entry)?
- specific commercial practice of the recipient (advertising, GTC clause, legal notice, price indication, labelling)
- prior history (earlier cease-and-desist letters from the same sender, industry practice)
- client's position: sender or recipient
- deadline situation (first knowledge, limitation period § 11 UWG)
Sub-agent architecture
Researcher supplies UWG statutes (§§ 3 et seq., 8 et seq., 13, 13a, 8c), BGH case law on requirements for senders and abuse of rights, as well as commentary passages. Drafter examines the effectiveness of the cease-and-desist letter in expert-opinion style and, depending on the client's side, drafts: (a) a cease-and-desist letter with a draft cease-and-desist declaration and calculation of costs, or (b) a modified cease-and-desist declaration / rejection letter / preparation of a protective brief. Reviewer checks deadlines (in particular § 11 UWG limitation period) and § 8c indications.
Process
1. Standing to sue of the sender
Entitled to claim pursuant to § 8 III UWG are:
- Competitors — a specific competitive relationship is required (§ 2 I No. 4 UWG). Low requirements, but not every market participant.
- Qualified trade associations (§ 8 III No. 2, § 8b UWG) — entry in the list at the Federal Office of Justice required; at least 75 businesses from the same sector; substantive/personnel resources; entered within the meaning of § 8b.
- Qualified institutions / consumer associations (§ 8 III No. 3) — entry under the UKlaG.
- Chambers of industry, commerce and crafts (§ 8 III No. 4).
In the case of associations: register entry must always be checked (BAJ list online).
2. Formal requirements § 13 II UWG
The cease-and-desist letter must contain:
- name or company of the sender and, where applicable, representation relationships
- requirements of entitlement to claim under § 8 III
- whether and in what amount reimbursement of expenses is asserted
- specific description of the infringement
- contractual penalty demand recognisable as the amount demanded
If one of these details is missing, the reimbursement of expenses under § 13 III UWG is excluded and the party receiving the cease-and-desist letter may have a counterclaim for reimbursement of its own legal defense costs (Section 13 V UWG).
3. Substantive basis of claim (Section 8 I in conjunction with Sections 3 et seq. UWG)
Order of examination in unfair competition law (cf. Köhler/Bornkamm/Feddersen, UWG, in each case current edition, Introduction paras. 4 et seq. [unverifiziert – prüfen]):
- Annex to Section 3 III UWG (Black List — per-se prohibition, no threshold of perceptibility)
- Sections 5, 5a, 5b UWG (misleading)
- Section 6 UWG (comparative advertising)
- Section 7 UWG (unreasonable harassment)
- Section 4 Nos. 1–4 UWG (protection of competitors)
- Section 4a UWG (aggressive practices)
- Section 3a UWG (breach of law)
- Section 3 II UWG (general clause)
4. Reimbursement of expenses Section 13 III UWG
Reimbursable are the necessary expenses:
- in the case of a lawyer's cease-and-desist letter: 1.3 business fee VV 2300 RVG according to the amount in dispute
- in the case of associations with their own legal department: flat-rate cost lump sum (case law as a rule EUR 230–280)
- in the case of a competitor's own cease-and-desist letter without a lawyer: no reimbursement of expenses (Section 13 IV UWG)
Amount in dispute: as a rule EUR 5,000–50,000 depending on the severity of the infringement; do not mechanically set at EUR 100,000.
5. Abuse of rights Section 8c UWG
Assertion is inadmissible if, taking into account all the circumstances, it is abusive (Section 8c I). Indications under Section 8c II (2021 amendment to the UWG):
- assertion of claims to a considerable extent against various debtors, if the assertion is disproportionate to the activity
- agreed or imposed contractual penalty obviously excessive
- excessive amount in dispute
- agreement of a contractual penalty for equivalent conduct, although a cease-and-desist declaration alone is sufficient
- cease-and-desist letter is obviously aimed at obtaining reimbursement of expenses/contractual penalty
- selection of debtors extraneous to the matter
Legal consequence: exclusion of claim + counterclaim of the party receiving the cease-and-desist letter for reimbursement of defense costs (Section 8c II 2 UWG).
6. Response options of the party receiving the cease-and-desist letter
| Option | When |
|---|---|
| Submit full cease-and-desist declaration (with contractual penalty) | Infringement clear, elimination of risk of repetition intended, limit cost risk |
| Modified cease-and-desist declaration (e.g. without reservation, with limited scope, lower contractual penalty according to Hamburg custom) | Infringement partly disputed, core theory problematic |
| Rejection (cease-and-desist letter unfounded / formally deficient / abusive) | Standing to sue lacking, Section 13 II not complied with, Section 8c indications |
| Negative declaratory action | Clarification of the non-existence of the claim desired; place of jurisdiction Section 32 ZPO |
| Protective brief with the Protective Brief Register | Anticipated imminent preliminary injunction |
According to the prevailing view, the risk of repetition is eliminated only by a penalty-backed cease-and-desist declaration (BGH, settled case law) [unverifiziert – prüfen in juris].
7. Contractual penalty § 13a UWG
The amount must be appropriate (§ 13a I UWG). Factors: nature/extent of the infringement, fault, economic significance. For small businesses / first infringement: EUR 2,500–5,100 per infringement is customary; for larger companies / repeat infringement: EUR 10,000 and more. In the case of a first infringement and a small business, the full contractual penalty may not readily be demanded pursuant to § 13a II UWG.
Sources and citation style
Binding: ../../../references/zitierweise.md.
Statute
- § 8 UWG (claim for injunctive relief and removal)
- § 8b UWG (trade associations)
- § 8c UWG (abuse of rights)
- § 11 UWG (6-month limitation period)
- § 13 UWG (cease-and-desist letter, reimbursement of expenses)
- § 13a UWG (contractual penalty)
- § 242 BGB (good faith)
- § 339 BGB (contractual penalty — forfeiture)
- § 32 ZPO (place of jurisdiction for tortious acts)
Commentaries
- Bornkamm, in: Köhler/Bornkamm/Feddersen, UWG, current edition, § 13 UWG marginal no. 1 et seq.
- Feddersen, in: Köhler/Bornkamm/Feddersen, UWG, current edition, § 8c UWG marginal no. 1 et seq.
- Goldmann, in: Harte-Bavendamm/Henning-Bodewig, UWG, 5th ed. 2021, § 13 UWG marginal no. 1 et seq.
- Sosnitza, in: Ohly/Sosnitza, UWG, 8th ed. 2023, § 13 UWG marginal no. 1 et seq.
Case law ([unverifiziert – prüfen in juris])
- BGH, judgment of 26.04.2018 – I ZR 248/16, GRUR 2018, 1166 – Abmahnaktion II (abuse of rights)
- BGH, judgment of 17.09.2015 – I ZR 92/14, GRUR 2016, 395 – Smartphone-Werbung (Hamburger custom)
- BGH, judgment of 04.07.2019 – I ZR 149/18, GRUR 2019, 1071 – Umwelthilfe (standing of association)
Output format (recipient's perspective)
GUTACHTEN — Prüfung UWG-Abmahnung
Mandant: <Abgemahnter, Branche, Größenklasse>
Abmahner: <Name, ggf. Verband, BAJ-Listen-Stand>
Zugang: <Datum>, Frist: <Datum>
I. Sachverhalt (knapp)
II. Kurzantwort
– Wirksamkeit der Abmahnung: [ja / formal mangelhaft / rechtsmissbräuchlich]
– Empfehlung: [vollständige UE / modifizierte UE / Zurückweisung / Schutzschrift]
III. Rechtliche Bewertung
1. Aktivlegitimation (§§ 8 III, 8b UWG)
2. Formelle Anforderungen § 13 II UWG
3. Materieller UWG-Verstoß
a) Anhang § 3 III (Schwarze Liste)?
b) §§ 5, 5a, 5b / 6 / 7 / 4 / 4a / 3a / 3 II UWG
4. Aufwendungsersatz § 13 III UWG (Gegenstandswert, RVG-Berechnung)
5. Rechtsmissbrauch § 8c UWG (Indizien-Katalog)
6. Vertragsstrafe § 13a UWG (Angemessenheit)
7. Verjährung § 11 UWG (Erstkenntnis-Daten)
IV. Reaktionsempfehlung
– Entwurf modifizierte UE / Zurückweisungsschreiben:
[zitierfähiger Block]
V. Risiken / offene Punkte
🟢 / 🟡 / 🔴 <Einstufung mit Begründung>
VI. Wiedervorlagen
– Reaktionsfrist Abmahner: <Datum>
– Verjährung § 11 UWG: <Datum + 6 Monate ab Kenntnis>
– ggf. Schutzschrift hinterlegt: <Datum>
VII. Quellenverzeichnis
Example (excerpt, expert opinion style)
2. Formal requirements § 13 II UWG. The cease-and-desist letter from V. e. V. dated TT.MM.JJJJ contains neither a reference to entry in the list of qualified trade associations (§ 13 II no. 2 in conjunction with § 8b UWG) nor a verifiable calculation of the expenses claimed (§ 13 II no. 3). This precludes the claim for reimbursement of expenses under § 13 III UWG; § 13 V UWG also establishes a counterclaim of the client for reimbursement of the necessary expenses for legal defense. Recommendation: reject with reference to § 13 II UWG and reserve the right to assert the counterclaim.
Risks / typical mistakes
- Standing of an association not verified — if there is no BAJ entry, the entire cease-and-desist letter is invalid.
- Seeking to eliminate the risk of repetition by a cease-and-desist declaration without a contractual penalty — risk of repetition only by a penalty-backed Cease-and-desist declaration cleared out; client remains exposed to litigation.
- Modified cease-and-desist declaration with too narrow a scope — core theory: minor deviations remain covered by the cease-and-desist declaration; too narrow a scope gives rise to a new risk of repetition.
- § 8c indications overlooked — in the case of mass cease-and-desist senders (association with disproportionate activity), examine the catalogue of indications in § 8c II No. 1.
- Limitation period under § 11 UWG missed — 6 months from knowledge, significantly shorter than § 195 BGB.
- Contractual penalty accepted as a lump sum — in the case of a first infringement / small business, invoke § 13a II UWG.
- Value in dispute accepted — consider a complaint against the value in dispute / auxiliary motion.