Deleting the message, rewriting git history or redacting the log does not un-expose a secret: the transcript, the remote, the backup and the provider's own logs already hold it. The only fix is to make the exposed value worthless — revoke it and issue a new one.
What went wrong on real projects is not ignorance of that. It is that the rotation was remembered instead of tracked: "rotate the exchange API keys" was carried forward through seven session logs; "keys that passed through chat" appeared in seven summaries of another project; a monitoring token pasted in plain text was never rotated. Each session wrote the reminder again and nobody owned it.
The moment you see one
- Never repeat the value. Not in your answer, not in a task title, not in a log, not
in a commit message. Name its kind and where it is: "OpenRouter API key, in the
operator's message of 22.09, 14:10".
scripts/lib/secret-patterns.mjsnames the kind. - Say it plainly, first line: this key is compromised; revoking it is the only fix.
- Open one task, not a note — in Beads if the project has it:
bd create "Rotate <kind> exposed in <where> on <date>" -t bug -p 0 \
-d "Exposed: <where>. Revoke at <provider console>, issue new, store in <secret store>, redeploy <consumers>, prove the old one is rejected."
Priority 0 for a production credential or anything that moves money; 1 otherwise. 4. If you can rotate it, rotate it — the operator asked you to handle it, or your task covers that system. If it needs the operator (a provider console you cannot reach, a hardware token), the task's first line says exactly what they must click.
Done means the old value is refused
A rotation is closed with evidence, not with "rotated":
- the new value is in the secret store the code reads — never in
CLAUDE.md,preferences.md, memory files, a README or any file that is loaded into a model's context (one key in a preferences file reached 605 transcripts); - every consumer was redeployed and uses it (
deploy-landed, config check); - a call with the old value fails — 401/403 from the provider. That is the proof.
Carrying it forward
An open rotation task older than 48 hours goes to the top of the next session's report
and of /inbox, with its age. Do not re-list it in the session log as a fresh item —
link the task. Re-writing a reminder is how the seven-session carry-over happened.